If you think about it this way, maybe Jacob will die...

[Pubic Genital Lice]

I just asked this very question to Stephenie on MTV.com. Here you can ask quetions to her too.

Quote:

Dear Stephenie, I have realized that each of the Cullens have lost something before they were turned into a vampire. Like Esme lost her baby, Alice lost her memory, and Edward lost his family. Now, if it was intended that way, then if Bella were to be turned into a vampire, would her loosing something before being turned be Jacob?

Now, I know she's not going to give out spoiler questions, which this sounds so much like. But after thinking over this question, it sounds like it's true. I mean just think about it for a second. It makes perfect sense! :]

Do you agree?  

[mto92]

eek wow i never thought of it that way before i hope he wont die or anything  

[Jellycones]

Wow, you make a really good point. I actually haven't thought of that to the slightest bit whatsoever...

The only thing I'm not sure of...is if that were the case, if she'd lose Jacob. She could loose anybody or anything if you really think about it.

Ahh, I really can't wait til' August 2nd now.  

[Pubic Genital Lice]

mto92

eek wow i never thought of it that way before i hope he wont die or anything

I kind of do.. redface

 

[Pubic Genital Lice]

Jellycones

Wow, you make a really good point. I actually haven't thought of that to the slightest bit whatsoever...

The only thing I'm not sure of...is if that were the case, if she'd lose Jacob. She could loose anybody or anything if you really think about it.

Ahh, I really can't wait til' August 2nd now.

You know if it'd be anyone or anything, it be Jacob that'd be the most certain. I mean each of the Cullen's lost some thing the most dearest to them. I mean Alice loosing her memory doesn't sound that great, but she lost her memory of family and past.

I feel like something is cooking up in Breaking Dawn. :]

 

[Jellycones]

Pubic Genital Lice

Jellycones

Wow, you make a really good point. I actually haven't thought of that to the slightest bit whatsoever...

The only thing I'm not sure of...is if that were the case, if she'd lose Jacob. She could loose anybody or anything if you really think about it.

Ahh, I really can't wait til' August 2nd now.

You know if it'd be anyone or anything, it be Jacob that'd be the most certain. I mean each of the Cullen's lost some thing the most dearest to them. I mean Alice loosing her memory doesn't sound that great, but she lost her memory of family and past.

I feel like something is cooking up in Breaking Dawn. :]

Ahh, I can't wait to read Breaking Dawn to see if you're right. One half of me thinks you're right, and one half of me doesn't want you to be right because I like Jacob... (not exactly as much as Edward...but still.)  

[Pubic Genital Lice]

Jellycones

Pubic Genital Lice

Jellycones

Wow, you make a really good point. I actually haven't thought of that to the slightest bit whatsoever...

The only thing I'm not sure of...is if that were the case, if she'd lose Jacob. She could loose anybody or anything if you really think about it.

Ahh, I really can't wait til' August 2nd now.

You know if it'd be anyone or anything, it be Jacob that'd be the most certain. I mean each of the Cullen's lost some thing the most dearest to them. I mean Alice loosing her memory doesn't sound that great, but she lost her memory of family and past.

I feel like something is cooking up in Breaking Dawn. :]

Ahh, I can't wait to read Breaking Dawn to see if you're right. One half of me thinks you're right, and one half of me doesn't want you to be right because I like Jacob... (not exactly as much as Edward...but still.)

I want to be right so bad. I'd feel so cool. :}

 

[Jellycones]

Pubic Genital Lice

Jellycones

Pubic Genital Lice

Jellycones

Wow, you make a really good point. I actually haven't thought of that to the slightest bit whatsoever...

The only thing I'm not sure of...is if that were the case, if she'd lose Jacob. She could loose anybody or anything if you really think about it.

Ahh, I really can't wait til' August 2nd now.

You know if it'd be anyone or anything, it be Jacob that'd be the most certain. I mean each of the Cullen's lost some thing the most dearest to them. I mean Alice loosing her memory doesn't sound that great, but she lost her memory of family and past.

I feel like something is cooking up in Breaking Dawn. :]

Ahh, I can't wait to read Breaking Dawn to see if you're right. One half of me thinks you're right, and one half of me doesn't want you to be right because I like Jacob... (not exactly as much as Edward...but still.)

I want to be right so bad. I'd feel so cool. :}

Well we can definately mark your word for it, if you are correct! xP You have a whole thread. ;D  

[Bubblie-san]

she should lose her klutzy-ness surprised  

[Pubic Genital Lice]

Jellycones

Pubic Genital Lice

Jellycones

Pubic Genital Lice

Jellycones

Wow, you make a really good point. I actually haven't thought of that to the slightest bit whatsoever...

The only thing I'm not sure of...is if that were the case, if she'd lose Jacob. She could loose anybody or anything if you really think about it.

Ahh, I really can't wait til' August 2nd now.

You know if it'd be anyone or anything, it be Jacob that'd be the most certain. I mean each of the Cullen's lost some thing the most dearest to them. I mean Alice loosing her memory doesn't sound that great, but she lost her memory of family and past.

I feel like something is cooking up in Breaking Dawn. :]

Ahh, I can't wait to read Breaking Dawn to see if you're right. One half of me thinks you're right, and one half of me doesn't want you to be right because I like Jacob... (not exactly as much as Edward...but still.)

I want to be right so bad. I'd feel so cool. :}

Well we can definately mark your word for it, if you are correct! xP You have a whole thread. ;D

Haha, if I am wrong, then it was a wrong lucky guess.

 

[Dine with the Damned]

Pubic Genital Lice

mto92

eek wow i never thought of it that way before i hope he wont die or anything

I kind of do.. redface

ya. im not a very big jacob fan.
(actually thats a bit of an understatement.)
he just better not try any funny s**t in Breaking Dawn
or i will hate him even more. (like crashing weddings.)
right now i look at his death as unnessisary. but if he tries
to do any last minute bella rescues from Edward, by all
means, kill him.
if he died, it wouldnt look like much of a
loss to me..... sweatdrop

anyway, you may be right, but, what did Emmett
lose? what did Carlisle lose? what did Jasper lose?

they lost their families, but not until after the change.

but, you may count that Carlisle lost his mother.

bella doesnt have to lose anything, at least, not yet.
she will lose something after the change. the same
thing that Emmett lost, their family. but you gain
another family in return.

but you may be right. a lot of people like to think
that jacob will die in Breaking Dawn. personally,
i dont think it will happen. stephenie loves jacob,
she wouldnt want to kill him. she knows a lot of
people will be upset. i dont disagree that
someone will die in Breaking Dawn, i just dont have
the faintest idea who.  

[Pubic Genital Lice]

Your My Brand Of Heroin

Pubic Genital Lice

mto92

eek wow i never thought of it that way before i hope he wont die or anything

I kind of do.. redface

ya. im not a very big jacob fan.
(actually thats a bit of an understatement.)
he just better not try any funny s**t in Breaking Dawn
or i will hate him even more. (like crashing weddings.)
right now i look at his death as unnessisary. but if he tries
to do any last minute bella rescues from Edward, by all
means, kill him.
if he died, it wouldnt look like much of a
loss to me..... sweatdrop

anyway, you may be right, but, what did Emmett
lose? what did Carlisle lose? what did Jasper lose?

they lost their families, but not until after the change.

but, you may count that Carlisle lost his mother.

bella doesnt have to lose anything, at least, not yet.
she will lose something after the change. the same
thing that Emmett lost, their family. but you gain
another family in return.

but you may be right. a lot of people like to think
that jacob will die in Breaking Dawn. personally,
i dont think it will happen. stephenie loves jacob,
she wouldnt want to kill him. she knows a lot of
people will be upset. i dont disagree that
someone will die in Breaking Dawn, i just dont have
the faintest idea who.

Actually, Carlisle lost his father or something. Jasper lost something, but I can't seem to remember it. We didn't learn much about Emmett though, but I am sure he lost something..

 

[Dine with the Damned]

Pubic Genital Lice

Your My Brand Of Heroin

Pubic Genital Lice

mto92

eek wow i never thought of it that way before i hope he wont die or anything

I kind of do.. redface

ya. im not a very big jacob fan.
(actually thats a bit of an understatement.)
he just better not try any funny s**t in Breaking Dawn
or i will hate him even more. (like crashing weddings.)
right now i look at his death as unnessisary. but if he tries
to do any last minute bella rescues from Edward, by all
means, kill him.
if he died, it wouldnt look like much of a
loss to me..... sweatdrop

anyway, you may be right, but, what did Emmett
lose? what did Carlisle lose? what did Jasper lose?

they lost their families, but not until after the change.

but, you may count that Carlisle lost his mother.

bella doesnt have to lose anything, at least, not yet.
she will lose something after the change. the same
thing that Emmett lost, their family. but you gain
another family in return.

but you may be right. a lot of people like to think
that jacob will die in Breaking Dawn. personally,
i dont think it will happen. stephenie loves jacob,
she wouldnt want to kill him. she knows a lot of
people will be upset. i dont disagree that
someone will die in Breaking Dawn, i just dont have
the faintest idea who.

Actually, Carlisle lost his father or something. Jasper lost something, but I can't seem to remember it. We didn't learn much about Emmett though, but I am sure he lost something..

hmm... it never said that Carlisle lost
his dad... just that his dad retired and
Carlisle took over.  

[Pubic Genital Lice]

Your My Brand Of Heroin

Pubic Genital Lice

Your My Brand Of Heroin

Pubic Genital Lice

mto92

eek wow i never thought of it that way before i hope he wont die or anything

I kind of do.. redface

ya. im not a very big jacob fan.
(actually thats a bit of an understatement.)
he just better not try any funny s**t in Breaking Dawn
or i will hate him even more. (like crashing weddings.)
right now i look at his death as unnessisary. but if he tries
to do any last minute bella rescues from Edward, by all
means, kill him.
if he died, it wouldnt look like much of a
loss to me..... sweatdrop

anyway, you may be right, but, what did Emmett
lose? what did Carlisle lose? what did Jasper lose?

they lost their families, but not until after the change.

but, you may count that Carlisle lost his mother.

bella doesnt have to lose anything, at least, not yet.
she will lose something after the change. the same
thing that Emmett lost, their family. but you gain
another family in return.

but you may be right. a lot of people like to think
that jacob will die in Breaking Dawn. personally,
i dont think it will happen. stephenie loves jacob,
she wouldnt want to kill him. she knows a lot of
people will be upset. i dont disagree that
someone will die in Breaking Dawn, i just dont have
the faintest idea who.

Actually, Carlisle lost his father or something. Jasper lost something, but I can't seem to remember it. We didn't learn much about Emmett though, but I am sure he lost something..

hmm... it never said that Carlisle lost
his dad... just that his dad retired and
Carlisle took over.

Hmm.

 

[5thmarauder]

Your My Brand Of Heroin

Pubic Genital Lice

Your My Brand Of Heroin

Pubic Genital Lice

mto92

eek wow i never thought of it that way before i hope he wont die or anything

I kind of do.. redface

ya. im not a very big jacob fan.
(actually thats a bit of an understatement.)
he just better not try any funny s**t in Breaking Dawn
or i will hate him even more. (like crashing weddings.)
right now i look at his death as unnessisary. but if he tries
to do any last minute bella rescues from Edward, by all
means, kill him.
if he died, it wouldnt look like much of a
loss to me..... sweatdrop

anyway, you may be right, but, what did Emmett
lose? what did Carlisle lose? what did Jasper lose?

they lost their families, but not until after the change.

but, you may count that Carlisle lost his mother.

bella doesnt have to lose anything, at least, not yet.
she will lose something after the change. the same
thing that Emmett lost, their family. but you gain
another family in return.

but you may be right. a lot of people like to think
that jacob will die in Breaking Dawn. personally,
i dont think it will happen. stephenie loves jacob,
she wouldnt want to kill him. she knows a lot of
people will be upset. i dont disagree that
someone will die in Breaking Dawn, i just dont have
the faintest idea who.

Actually, Carlisle lost his father or something. Jasper lost something, but I can't seem to remember it. We didn't learn much about Emmett though, but I am sure he lost something..

hmm... it never said that Carlisle lost
his dad... just that his dad retired and
Carlisle took over.

in a way though he did loose his dad realy. His father was retired but by becoming a vampire he lost any respect that he may have had with his father. He would no longer be counted as his son realy if he had known what charlisle became. He would just as soon kill Charlisle as he would any other vampire.