Is he, or isn't he? SPOILERS

[Awkward Biscuit]

HBP SPOILERS AHEAD!



Now I know this is kind of an overused topic, but I found this awesome site called
www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com It has some great reasons on why our favorite headmaster may still be alive. But sadly, after much thought, I still believe him dead. What about you?  

[dreamr-j]

actually i think its very convincing.. prolly cuz half of me believes he's alive.. i hope he is..  

[Awkward Biscuit]

I hope so too. But I dunno, he was like Harry's pillar, and now its time for Harry to stand on his own. It makes sense he's gone.  

[xX Kalliandra Mori Xx]

No just like Sirius he is DEAD. I know it may be sad but I really think he has kicked the bucket this time.

 

[Cestria]

He's dead. You can't just kill off a character and bring him back to life, even with magic. There's a reason for everything that JK Rowling writes, and there's for sure a reason for his death.

 

[Pow in the Wow]

he's gonna b dead sad  

[ForsakenWings]

Dumbledore is dead

Sirius is not, even if no further mention of him is ever brought up, the word "dead" does not define whatever happened to him.

Severus is not evil.

Harry WILL die in book 7, as will Voldemort. Whether or not Severus will be killed before then, and by which side, is still too iffy.  

[The Red Coyote]

I think He is but I think I is not. I can figure it out. I think that he is dead but sometimes i think he is not dead. And Snape is NOT evil. there are way to many points showing that he is good. If he was evil why would he have been giving Harry tips after he killed Dumbledore? I think he is good and my mom says he is her hero. It is kind of sad but if you think about it he IS MY HERO TO! NEHE! I think that Harry and Voldemort both die. I think but i hope not. HARRY IS TO CUTE to die.  

[Roytjuh]

Well i haven't read the book yet because the new harry potter book isn't out yet in Holland where i come from. At least not in Dutch. But if he died than there is no turning back for him. Very Sad. sad  

[The Red Coyote]

Roytjuh

Well i haven't read the book yet because the new harry potter book isn't out yet in Holland where i come from. At least not in Dutch. But if he died than there is no turning back for him. Very Sad. sad

Oh darn. You have not read it yet. Crappy!  

[killaloose]

xX Kalliandra Mori Xx

No just like Sirius he is DEAD. I know it may be sad but I really think he has kicked the bucket this time.

I hope so. Don't get me wrong, I love him to death, but to just bring back any character that Harry has lost would undermine the whole lesson of having to grow up and endure hardships. Dumbledore said it himself, he's not the important one here. It's Harry. And JKR spelled it out for us when Harry said he was finally not going to rely on anyone else. To take that back would be the opposite of the whole point of his death, and therefore would cheapen what had been done, and undermine Harry's growth as a character and is therefore... impossible? Sure.  

[Darkaznstargoddess]

He's dead..
I think it was to set the stage where it's Voldie vs Harry.
Now that the people that were suppose to protect him are gone.  

[The Red Coyote]

I agree with you two!  

[Fiyun]

I prefer that the former headmaster stays dead, as he has already played his role and provided Harry with some things to be expected in a book.
(Though we never know before next book, Dumbledore could have done a "Resident Evil"-move like some of the characters like Ada or Wesker did.)  

[Sixguns]

He's dead. Get used to it.