Studying on dead people ! | Page 1 | ☪)Islamic Discussion(☪ | Guild Forums

The_Pathan
Captain

Offline

Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2009 11:51 am

Asalam Alaykum smile

I was wondering if it's haram or halal, to study/cut on dead people, and check them. As many nurses and doctors do.

3nodding Please explain smile

Posted: Mon Sep 28, 2009 3:13 pm

The_Pathan

Asalam Alaykum smile

I was wondering if it's haram or halal, to study/cut on dead people, and check them. As many nurses and doctors do.

3nodding Please explain smile

if u rllllllly have to then yes
but generally it is haram because when you die you still can feel and hear etc... plus other abilities. so if some1 cuts u open u feel that
and wen ur dead it feels 100xs more painful. it is said that if a fly is on a dead person it feels like a ton.

XxXZero_BeatXxX

Offline

Shinigami Vayth
Crew

Newbie Hunter

Offline

Posted: Mon Sep 28, 2009 9:29 pm

XxXZero_BeatXxX

if u rllllllly have to then yes
but generally it is haram because when you die you still can feel and hear etc... plus other abilities. so if some1 cuts u open u feel that
and wen ur dead it feels 100xs more painful. it is said that if a fly is on a dead person it feels like a ton.

Uhh.. I never heard that though.. All I know is once a person is dead, the spirit is disconnected from his body..
There's a story about the body is broken (burnt, etc) when the grave is dug because he's being punished in Kubur, but I've never heard about the opposite, the body is affecting the spirit.
But I can't really say I'm right 100%. Spiritual realm is outside our reach after all..

IMO, if it's for study (human anatomy or autopsy), it's alright.

Posted: Tue Sep 29, 2009 5:18 am

Litsen, i think the mujahideen soldier is right 3nodding

Cause my mom tells me stuff like "don't have anything burning at a graveyard" and "dont walk on graves" cause if u walk at them it hurts. And if u got anything burning, then it is the feeling of hell.

3nodding

smile But ratri ( a nurse who told me ) says the people deside to be studied on, themselves sweatdrop

Now it's good to know this beffore u start doing it.

And i was wondering how does it feel if u get eaten by a shark? Then it feels like ur shark-poo when u are death? rofl

The_Pathan
Captain

Offline

The_Pathan
Captain

Offline

Posted: Tue Sep 29, 2009 5:20 am

People say the soul gets away, and some people say it stays in the body until day of judgement.

What is right? smile

People say a wife can't touch her husbands body, cause she's not married to the body, but soul.

And people say ur gonna sleep in ur grave till day of judgement(but it feels like sleeping 1 night)

Posted: Tue Sep 29, 2009 5:21 am

This is confusing. Only God knows better....... xp

hfzl1234

5,500 Points

100
100
200

Offline

XxXZero_BeatXxX

Offline

Posted: Tue Sep 29, 2009 12:24 pm

The_Pathan

People say the soul gets away, and some people say it stays in the body until day of judgement.

What is right? smile

People say a wife can't touch her husbands body, cause she's not married to the body, but soul.

And people say ur gonna sleep in ur grave till day of judgement(but it feels like sleeping 1 night)

the soul leaves the body wen it is buried and the people who buried it
has to step 25ft away from the grave then the angel of death comes.
and the part wen u sleep in ur grave is wrong. the angel of death will ask u the 3 questions that im sure u know of.
if u get it right u go to a " temporary heaven" but it will feel very short. until the day of judgement comes. if u get it wrong u will get punished temporary until the day of judgement, but it will feel long.

Posted: Wed Sep 30, 2009 12:52 am

omg really?

I heard soo many diffrent stories sweatdrop

But i guess it makes sence what u just said smile

So u get in a temporary hell/paradise smile

But the angels what will they ask? Isen't it who is your prophet? who is your god? what is your religion?

or was it: How to pray? lol

The_Pathan
Captain

Offline

XxXZero_BeatXxX

Offline

Posted: Wed Sep 30, 2009 2:08 pm

The_Pathan

omg really?

I heard soo many diffrent stories sweatdrop

But i guess it makes sence what u just said smile

So u get in a temporary hell/paradise smile

But the angels what will they ask? Isen't it who is your prophet? who is your god? what is your religion?

or was it: How to pray? lol

nope
u got the questions right lol
who is your prophet? who is your god? what is your religion?

Posted: Thu Oct 01, 2009 5:12 am

Wont the angel ask u how to pray? :O

The_Pathan
Captain

Offline

Welcome to Gaia! ::

Gaia Guilds

The Muslim Guild Of Gaia

Quick Reply

More Information