Hajj x 2 = haram?

[The_Pathan]

Asalam Alaykum! =)

I've been wodnering about if Hajj more than once was haram. (and I would like You guys to discuss it).

I've got this in mind, cuz lotsa people may go, and then there is no space to do hajj, cuz the rich people who go to hajj every year, tock all the space.

Isn't that haram? going to hajj all the time, so the poor people who try going there can't enter?

People go to hajj sumtimes cuz they did bad stuff, and then they think that if they go to hajj they are forgiven. And they always do like that. And lotsa people, instead of behaving nice in the house of Allah. They start punching people, and being violent.

So I was just wondering smile  

[Max-less]

Well, to go to Hajj more than once is NOT haram. Actually we should go hajj more than once (if we could) because maybe some didn't do it good that time.

But, like you said, people should let others to have a chance to do it, too.

I leave in Makka/Mecca so I know how much people go Hajj. Believe me there are TOO many people.  

[The_Pathan]

You live in Mecca? Don't You live in Riyad confused

I think it was ok to go there if You live at Mekka and it was many years ago. But today the population grew pretty much, and it's not that good being greedy. I don't think Allah will forgive You, if You are being violent (as in punching people).  

[Max-less]

The_Pathan

You live in Mecca? Don't You live in Riyad confused

I think it was ok to go there if You live at Mekka and it was many years ago. But today the population grew pretty much, and it's not that good being greedy. I don't think Allah will forgive You, if You are being violent (as in punching people).

Yes, I live in Mecca. cheese_whine Fish lives in Riyad.

And being violent is bad in all matters.  

[PlusleChu]

not haram. ^^
going to hajj more than once is good. i can go for myself or for another muslim who is dead or sick to clear out his/her sins. ^^
doing something good for someone else affects the person positively. 3nodding  

[Lysander the silent]

Max-less

The_Pathan

You live in Mecca? Don't You live in Riyad confused

I think it was ok to go there if You live at Mekka and it was many years ago. But today the population grew pretty much, and it's not that good being greedy. I don't think Allah will forgive You, if You are being violent (as in punching people).

Yes, I live in Mecca. cheese_whine Fish lives in Riyad.

And being violent is bad in all matters.

Agreed on the violence part.  

[The_Pathan]

It's fine to be viollent sumtimes wink

But my step-grandpa said "why should I go to Hajj? Did I do anything wrong? Only people who did gunha(sins) goes there. "LOOOL  

[PlusleChu]

^ does he know if everything he does is good? did he gossip? did he lie? did he pick on someone?
no one lives without mistakes. xd  

[dark__sunshin]

nooo!!
of course it's not haram =)
my dad did it maybe 3 times! XD 3nodding  

[The_Pathan]

And my dad did it 0 times, (cuz of time actually) but cuz sum people have to do it 5 times razz  

[dark__sunshin]

The_Pathan

And my dad did it 0 times, (cuz of time actually) but cuz sum people have to do it 5 times razz

Good Thing We Live Near Saudia ;D.. 2hours by plane n' we're there =D.. steady and ready 2 do alhajj!  

[The_Pathan]

Ehh. it's like 7 hours here I bet.

But Saudi is a joy xD!!! I heard the price of meat in saudi, is the same as water. And oil is the same as air. xd  

[WandySama]

The_Pathan

Ehh. it's like 7 hours here I bet.

But Saudi is a joy xD!!! I heard the price of meat in saudi, is the same as water. And oil is the same as air. xd

lol you are kidding
everything has a price maybe a little cheaper but nothing is free and we have poor people who starve for days to make ends meet.

bout hajj everyone has to do it and tell your grandpa he has to more than anyone cuz he denied a a rokon (pillar) in islam.

about the pushing.

It is done by ignorant Muslims who we should pity.


i went to hajj one time and im not satisfied.
i was always worrying about doing things right and proper that i didn't feel the spirituality of it all.  

[The_Pathan]

He is my steph grandpa, not my real. He smoke and drink alcohol, and my mom don't like him. What shall I explain to him???

Ya ur right, you gotta know what to do, not like going there, then asking around, hehe =)

But it's a special place, and wonderful to look at.


About the price. No one would survive in Denmark. We pay highest tax in world. 50%, if ur rich it's more, if ur not that strong economically u pay less.

plus, muslims pay Zakaat.

Why u think the banks are so rich? when the danes become 18, they leave their family and loan from bank and live by themselves.

It's said that a 5 star hotel's meat, is cheaper than the toilet water in Denmark.

It's also said their oil used to be free, now it's not free, but it's really really cheap!!! And in Denmark it's really expensive, soooo. Saudi is kinda luxurious to live xD! (as long as they got their oil)