:D tifa vs aerith who would win for clouds love

[KureshentoLucrecia]

biggrin
well who would win tifa or aerith
well i think aerith cause she can heal her slef  

[The Real Raijin]

Perhaps if Aerith didn't get killed and if she wasn't Zack's girl.
Cloud did give Tifa a hard time in the game...  

[KureshentoLucrecia]

The Real Raijin

Perhaps if Aerith didn't get killed and if she wasn't Zack's girl.
Cloud did give Tifa a hard time in the game...

i agree in crisis core aerith moved on too quickly and she used to love Zack not until she saw cloud  

[Princess Augustine]

In a legitimate combat fight, I would say Tifa.Aerith is stastisically built to be a party's back row (Low HP, high magic capabilities). She doesn't have much of a defense if she's directly battling Tifa, who wouldn't give her enough time to cloak herself in defensive spells.
It would also depend on the materia/armor build Aerith and Tifa are given. Aerith has a chance at winning, should she be outfitted with strong offensive magic materia and a epuipment set that would enhance those statistics while giving her sturdy defense against Tifa's physical attacks. I would still say Tifa, who doesn't have to cast spells to damage an opponent.

In terms of the Love Triangle debate: Tifa, no questions asked. Cloud admitted he had feelings for Tifa before the final battle, as clarified in the Ultimania. And Crisis Core made it blatantly obvious that ZackxAerith was canon. So yeah, my two cents. ^^;

 

[x Imaginary Sinner x]

Comin' from a Cloud who knows... I'm engaged to a Tifa... so yeah, that settles the debate on my end...  

[Official Genesis]

Tifa, you should be ashamed Aerith, you're totally Zack's girlfriend.  

[Official Genesis]

Also how does the abilities to heal one's physical wounds factor into winning a male suitor's heart?  

[Sakuya794]

..... Wow. I am ashamed of everyone here. You all don't read up on the game or the characters, do you? =/

I'm an avid Aerith fan. I read up on everything about her, I've studied her and the game(s) ever since they first came out.

Aerith has stated many MANY times that she's over Zack. She's not Zack's girl anymore. She has also stated she loves Cloud. Many times. -__-

(Rant below, in a smaller text)

Yes, ZackxAerith was canon in the past, but then she moved on after he was gone for 4 years. She was heart broken, yes, and she did like him, but it was her first taste of love and the creators themselves say they love each other as best friends. In the events of FFVII ----> Advent Children Aerith loves Cloud and no one else.

With that rant out of the way, I think Aerith has already won. From what I've seen in all the games and movies Cloud treats Aerith differently than Tifa. With Tifa, he treats her like she's one of the guys, but he himself states that he's Aerith's bodyguard and brings it up quite a few times. He also took the offer with only a date as payment. Then when she's kidnapped he storms into Shinra to get her back without a plan in mind. Then when she dies he's completely shattered.

Also, after Aerith leads Cloud back out of his consciousness, while Tifa is in his arms, he states how he wants to meet Aerith in the promised land, disregarding Tifa's feelings immediately.

In Advent Children and CoT, Cloud and Tifa are having problems. I remember distinctly a scene where Cloud had just delivered flowers from Elmyra to Aerith's grave and he was drinking wine. Tifa offers to drink with him but he says he wants to drink alone, then she says to drink in his room.
When Cloud finds Denzel he says he believes Aerith sent him to him, but Tifa corrects him saying he's wrong.

After all's said and done, Cloud runs off to live in Aerith's church. Then she comes back to him, helps him get on the path of forgiving himself. The creators say she's the only one that can help him with this. He's seeking forgiveness from Aerith. She heals him, helps him in battle, saves him from death, and lives in his consciousness and is engraved in his heart.

Now... this has turned into a rant, but I was deeply upset that no one knows Aerith's character at all! She has gotten over Zack and is in love with Cloud canon-wise! D<

Yes, the creators have put it up to interpretation who Cloud loves, but I believe Cloud's heart belongs to Aerith. Argue with me however much you want, but my opinion won't change anytime soon, I assure you.


ANYWAY! Onto the topic. Aerith would win. >>  

[IXI Pyramid Head IxI]

Zack and Aerith together arn't they?
Tifa and cloud should be together =P  

[Aerith Great Gospel]

Both AerithxZack and AerithxCloud are canon. AerithxZack is obvious, since they were a couple during Crisis Core up until his death at the end of Crisis Core. Tetsuya Nomura has stated that Aerith and Cloud are a canon couple (I had a picture of the source somewhere, I'll have to find it again sometime). However, do I think that makes Aerith and Cloud the ultimate couple? No, I do not. To me, personally. I find AerithxZack the legit couple. For starters, Zack was the only person (That we know of) that Aerith ever had a relationship with on a 'more than friends' basis. Though Aerith went on a date with Cloud at the Gold Saucer, and she offered it as a reward for protecting her from The Turks in her church, I always felt it was a way to imitate Zack a/o to settle down her hurt feelings from Zack's death, since Cloud looked exactly like him, though Blonde. Even if none of the above are true, we can stay this: Aerith was drawn to Cloud by one thing: The fact that he looks like Zack. Nothing else. Therefore, her feelings truly lie for Zack Fair, and not for Cloud Strife as a person. The memory of Zack Fair stays dear to her always, and it is very prominent in the examples I gave. She even told Cloud that he reminded her of 'him' (referring to Zack), indicating her natural curiosity and how she could be drawn to him.

Also, Sakura794, please, feel free to enlighten me with credible source as to where you've found your information that Aerith has said she is over Zack/loves Cloud. I'm itching to know. /no sarcasm.



Sources: Playing the game, being the biggest Aerith fan in the world.

Back on topic: Between Aerith and Tifa, ultimately? Probably Tifa. I'm sure eventually Tifa and Cloud would get together, due to Tifa's dedication to Cloud. If Aerith hadn't died, I'm honestly not sure, though he and Aerith probably would have gotten together, it would be for the reasons I provided above to promote Aerith's infatuation.  

[KureshentoLucrecia]

Sakuya794

..... Wow. I am ashamed of everyone here. You all don't read up on the game or the characters, do you? =/

I'm an avid Aerith fan. I read up on everything about her, I've studied her and the game(s) ever since they first came out.

Aerith has stated many MANY times that she's over Zack. She's not Zack's girl anymore. She has also stated she loves Cloud. Many times. -__-

(Rant below, in a smaller text)
[es, ZackxAerith was canon in the past, but then she moved on after he wasize=7]
Ys gone for 4 years. She was heart broken, yes, and she did like him, but it was her first taste of love and the creators themselves say they love each other as best friends. In the events of FFVII ----> Advent Children Aerith loves Cloud and no one else.

With that rant out of the way, I think Aerith has already won. From what I've seen in all the games and movies Cloud treats Aerith differently than Tifa. With Tifa, he treats her like she's one of the guys, but he himself states that he's Aerith's bodyguard and brings it up quite a few times. He also took the offer with only a date as payment. Then when she's kidnapped he storms into Shinra to get her back without a plan in mind. Then when she dies he's completely shattered.

Also, after Aerith leads Cloud back out of his consciousness, while Tifa is in his arms, he states how he wants to meet Aerith in the promised land, disregarding Tifa's feelings immediately.

In Advent Children and CoT, Cloud and Tifa are having problems. I remember distinctly a scene where Cloud had just delivered flowers from Elmyra to Aerith's grave and he was drinking wine. Tifa offers to drink with him but he says he wants to drink alone, then she says to drink in his room.
When Cloud finds Denzel he says he believes Aerith sent him to him, but Tifa corrects him saying he's wrong.

After all's said and done, Cloud runs off to live in Aerith's church. Then she comes back to him, helps him get on the path of forgiving himself. The creators say she's the only one that can help him with this. He's seeking forgiveness from Aerith. She heals him, helps him in battle, saves him from death, and lives in his consciousness and is engraved in his heart.

Now... this has turned into a rant, but I was deeply upset that no one knows Aerith's character at all! She has gotten over Zack and is in love with Cloud canon-wise! D<

Yes, the creators have put it up to interpretation who Cloud loves, but I believe Cloud's heart belongs to Aerith. Argue with me however much you want, but my opinion won't change anytime soon, I assure you.


ANYWAY! Onto the topic. Aerith would win. >>

on to the fact zack...made her wait and...cloud flet guilty after she died  

[KureshentoLucrecia]

Official Genesis

Tifa, you should be ashamed Aerith, you're totally Zack's girlfriend.

but....i dont have a zack O_o
and my bf cosplayed as a cloud
O.o in rl so im gonna cosplay as aerith : 3  

[Sakuya794]

Aerith Gainsboroug FFVII

Official Genesis

Tifa, you should be ashamed Aerith, you're totally Zack's girlfriend.

but....i dont have a zack O_o
and my bf cosplayed as a cloud
O.o in rl so im gonna cosplay as aerith : 3

That shouldn't change your opinion, dear. XD I cosplay Aerith myself and all I get are Zacks. -__- I got a Cloud once and we met in a dating game, believe it or not.  

[KureshentoLucrecia]

Sakuya794

Aerith Gainsboroug FFVII

Official Genesis

Tifa, you should be ashamed Aerith, you're totally Zack's girlfriend.

but....i dont have a zack O_o
and my bf cosplayed as a cloud
O.o in rl so im gonna cosplay as aerith : 3

That shouldn't change your opinion, dear. XD I cosplay Aerith myself and all I get are Zacks. -__- I got a Cloud once and we met in a dating game, believe it or not.

so..true cloud has more compassion to aerith in the movie he did not think about her he blamed himslef that he let her die