Is Harry the Descendant oif Godric Gryffindor???????????

[R J Lupin]

What do you think?  

[R J Lupin]

This is what I think:

When he was sorted, he could have been put in Ravenclaw (not a bad mind) or Slytherin as the sorting hat had said. But instead it was gryffindor because Harry said not Slytherin. When Harry got out of the chamber after defeating Tom Riddle and the can't spell Baslisk or what ever it is. Dumbledore said only a true Gryffindor could have pulled that out of the hat. Maybe not someone from the school house but someone of Gryffindor blood. Harry lived in a town called Godrics Hallow. His father was in Gryffindor.
Godric and Salazaar fought and the fight was never finished. Now the heir of Slytherin will Finish the Filght with The Heir of Gryffindor.  

[Elliot Salem]

The reason the Sorting Hat suggested Slytherin was because When Voldemort tried to kill him, he gained some of his dark powers. But what Dumbledore said could mean 'Only the bravest and boldest can pull Godric Grffindor's sword out of the Sorting Hat.'  

[Riku Stratus]

Its also based on the traits the sorting hat looks for when it puts the students into their houses. Gryffindor put alot of stock in bravery and being true to ones friends. As we have seen, Harry has displayed these traits time and time again. So, when Dumbledore said that only a true Gryffindor could have pulled the sword out of the hat, he was telling Harry two things. First and the more important thing is that he is completely different from Voldermort. Second, being that the choices they make dictate the lives that they lead. To really support the first point.  

[R J Lupin]

I Know the part about the sorting hat. And I know about Slytherin. But Harry also according to the hat although it never said it He had the traits of a ravenclaw too.  

[ofbittersweetmemories]

I honestly don't think he could be the heir of Gryffindor. They would have mentioned it by now.  

[CuteLittleRin]

ladyrampage

I honestly don't think he could be the heir of Gryffindor. They would have mentioned it by now.

ya i agreee  

[dirty old sod]

I doubt it, but we will just have to wait for the next book.  

[covo]

@R J Lupin: You have made some really good points but I just don't believe that Harry is the heir. But if he is the heir, that would make a really good plot twist for the next book.  

[darkzumi]

That would be cool if he was.  

[RedRose07]

R J Lupin

This is what I think:

When he was sorted, he could have been put in Ravenclaw (not a bad mind) or Slytherin as the sorting hat had said. But instead it was gryffindor because Harry said not Slytherin. When Harry got out of the chamber after defeating Tom Riddle and the can't spell Baslisk or what ever it is. Dumbledore said only a true Gryffindor could have pulled that out of the hat. Maybe not someone from the school house but someone of Gryffindor blood. Harry lived in a town called Godrics Hallow. His father was in Gryffindor.
Godric and Salazaar fought and the fight was never finished. Now the heir of Slytherin will Finish the Filght with The Heir of Gryffindor.

that makes alot of sense  

[non642]

I don't think Harry is the heir. I don't know exactly why, just a feeling.

I wonder if Neville could be the heir since the prophesy could have applied to him and in the beginning he didn't show a lot of Gryffindor house traits, he seemed more Hufflepuff like. (yes I know there is the whole "standing up to friends" thing and other little examples like that, but overall his personality doesn't scream Gryffindor at first glance)  

[Nachttoter]

[ Message temporarily off-line ]  

[non642]

[ Message temporarily off-line ]  

[LeighMae]

RedRose07

R J Lupin

This is what I think:

When he was sorted, he could have been put in Ravenclaw (not a bad mind) or Slytherin as the sorting hat had said. But instead it was gryffindor because Harry said not Slytherin. When Harry got out of the chamber after defeating Tom Riddle and the can't spell Baslisk or what ever it is. Dumbledore said only a true Gryffindor could have pulled that out of the hat. Maybe not someone from the school house but someone of Gryffindor blood. Harry lived in a town called Godrics Hallow. His father was in Gryffindor.
Godric and Salazaar fought and the fight was never finished. Now the heir of Slytherin will Finish the Filght with The Heir of Gryffindor.

that makes alot of sense

Same here. 3nodding