Emwah's Critique

[EmWah]

For those who can handle the truth!

As an ex art student, I am well schooled in the theories of colour, line, position, juxtopostion, shape, flow, tone, structure and so on.
So, you know, I can tell you stuff and junk. ninja

So come one, come all and get rated!

Oh Emwah how do you rate?

Okay, here in Emwah's house of rating I give you points according to:
Shape, use of color, flow, balance, style and most importantly originality.
Points are taken away when these things are lacking. 3nodding
I really looove avatars that are original and different! So if you want to impress me, show me something I've never seen before! domokun

The Honour Roll
These people have scored a mighty 10/10 for their avatars
Chemical Kitten
JokerKyo
Wellzy X4
Fuzakeru Baka
thegreatvincenzo
ManagerKyoto

These people have scored 10/10 for other things
Wellzy (For his lovely cat Garfield, and political statement)

 

[StreekG]

*first person*  

[iamNOTanidiot]

rate my two avies
 

[Lai Woun]

rate meh  

[Darek Khort]

Me >.<  

[nrasjaa]

YOU STEALING MAH BUSINESS!! scream scream

THIS MEANS WAR!!! scream *gets her armour and amunition ready* scream scream

i'll show you nice stare  

[EmWah]

StreekG

*first person*

Hmmn okay.

I have to say I'm not a fan of your current hair style, but maybe it would look a bit better without the cape, because the cape kinda makes you look like you've got a bob, instead of long flowing god-locks.

Overall, the outfit is okay, but it looks rather flat. Once again I think this is because of the cape, which takes focus away from the fairy wings and hair.

I think you can do much better 3nodding

6/10  

[Weylok]

*Raises hand* Mememememe!  

[EmWah]

Magnus Ignatius

rate my two avies

Outfit 1:
Ahh, the old hoody and phat pants trick. Although this combo goes quite well together, it is quite overused in the world of gaia. It is quite plain, demands little imagination and does not command attention.

4/10

Outfit 2:

Much better. Although this outfit is still quite simple, it rates much higher in teh sex stakes. Your face and hair is free, putting focus on the coolness of those romanis. The jacket and snowboard pants work well together, and the blue shoes create a 'flow' (sorry to steal your word nras, but there's' really no other word to use!) through the outfit.

6.5/10  

[EmWah]

Lai Woun

rate meh

Ooh Lai Woun, I do quite like your avatar. She's so darn cute! Everything fits so nicely together and makes your cute face the focal point. The only thing I can pull you up on is your lack of shoes. The socks do match the outfit, but all female gaian avatars have terribly small feet, so if you don't wear shoes it kinda just looks like you have nubs there.

8.5/10  

[n00dlez0rz]

rate me please  

[EmWah]

Darek Khort

Me >.<

Mmmm I like indeed.

It screams LOOK AT ME. Yukata, winged anklets and OMG = heart
The lunar cloak, although quite often misused, is used quite well with this outfit. There is something weird about that jacket though... I think it's the pumpkins on the shoulder, which kinda take away from the outfit... maybe also the discman has something to do with it...

8/10  

[EmWah]

nrasjaa

YOU STEALING MAH BUSINESS!! scream scream

THIS MEANS WAR!!! scream *gets her armour and amunition ready* scream scream

i'll show you nice stare

Aww I'd never want to take business away from you and I'm sure that this thread will prove no more than some healthy competition. Anyway, you're the ratings queen! I could never take that away from you. This can be good bit of variety for the guild as well.

I hope I didn't offend you or anything. You are still my number 1 ratings girl, and the only person I ever go to to get rated mrgreen heart  

[EmWah]

Weylok

*Raises hand* Mememememe!

This outfit is really quite plain. In this combination, the items lack personality. I think this outfit could be improved with a couple more items... maybe something on your head would be good, or a demonic staff or another item that adds some volume to your avatar.

4.5/10  

[Lai Woun]

look! shoesies!!