Emmett or Edward??? Eh???

[starbrybaby]

Okay, so if for some weird, out-of-context reason Edward and Emmett got into a physical brawl, who do you think would win???

Tough, right?  

[Fifii]

not at all, my man Emmett would whoop edward, he'd take him down to china town.  

[The Kraken]

Hm, tough one, tough one. Emmett is clearly stronger than Edward, but then Edward would most likely run away instead of fight. So, I dunno.  

[Fifii]

The Kraken

Hm, tough one, tough one. Emmett is clearly stronger than Edward, but then Edward would most likely run away instead of fight. So, I dunno.

right he'd run away and thus forfeit, making Emmett the winner  

[Muzik_Freek]

that is tough, but i believe that ii could go either way,but as much as I hate to say it, Emmett would probably win  

[IntotheDestiny]

I'm not totally sure....I love Edward a lot (just like every other girl) but I guess Emmett.  

[xvanyaa]

I'm pretty sure it would be Emmett because he's a lot stronger even though they're both strong. So, yeah, it'd have to be Emmett.

 

[Copacetic Gloom]

That's a tough one. Emmett obviously defeats Edward when it comes to strength but I think that Edward would have a better strategy so it could go either way.  

[Kellkolo]

Edward, he could read Emmet's thoughts and predict his next moves, thus being able to dodge them! domokun

 

[Fifii]

Kellkolo

Edward, he could read Emmet's thoughts and predict his next moves, thus being able to dodge them! domokun

true but that only goes so far because when edward makes his move to win it won't work because emmett is so much stronger, that's his gift remember, and vampires don't get tired, so edward would be able to do nothing but evade.  

[Moonlite Romance]

Kellkolo

Edward, he could read Emmet's thoughts and predict his next moves, thus being able to dodge them! domokun

i agree, even though Emmett is alot stronger than Edward, edward has an advantage with the mind reading, and yea, he pretty much would evade all of emmetts attack, but edward has an advantage, and he can lure emmett and attack him when he least expects it!  

[Fifii]

i disagree, and i'm not sure lure is the right work, i think the right word is provoke.  

[kiyamasho]

hmmm... like everyon else has said thats a tough question! emmet would definately win if it were wrestling or something like that but remember edward could read emmet's thoughts so he def. has the advantage there. also edward is more "lithe" than emmett so....

arg!

idk who would win XD all that analyzing hurt my brain!  

[featherbee]

since emmetts strength is his enhanced power (i think) he would probably win even though edward has super strength too.  

[lady_ruler_of_the_zombies]

Good things come in small packages. Wait, what does that have to do with anything? Okay, just because Emmett's big and frickin heck a strong doesn't mean he'll win. Then again, just because Edward can read his mind doesn't mean that he'll win either. ( heart I love you Edward!!!) But Edward probably could outmanuever Emmett allowing him to win! Then again, it could go vice versa where Emmett takes him out in one blow. lol! But I'm going to choose Edward, just because I think he's more likely to win.