Good Idea, Bad Idea.

[Nelowulf]

Good Idea: Ticking a warlord off and brainwashing him to think someone else did it, after turning him into a four-armed cyborg.

Bad Idea: Ticking off the chosen one and trying to brainwash his son, after turning him into a black robed cyborg.  

[Darkened Angel]

Good idea: Being another bounty hunter in a room with Boba Fett.

Bad idea: Being another bounty in a room with Boba Fett.  

[FrozenPhoenix32]

GI: Messing with a Gungan

BI: Messing with a Corellian  

[Sol Walker]

Good Idea: Setting up missions for BOV
Bad Idea: Having FP set up those missions  

[Missing00]

GI: Joining BOV

BI: Not posting after joining BOV.  

[Darkened Angel]

Good idea: Posting in COTGCW RPs involving other regulars.

Bad idea: Doing so when they stop posting and you're stuck until they do something.  

[FrozenPhoenix32]

Cale Darksun

Good Idea: Setting up missions for BOV
Bad Idea: Having FP set up those missions

That was messeeed.

Fine dammit, since ND has like..died, you can be my new partner in crime.  

[Darkened Angel]

Good idea: BoV's Iota being played by an intelligent and classy woman.

Bad idea: BoV's Iota being played by DA. [deleted scene where Iota has fun with a Seperatist sexbot here]  

[elvisnake]

Good Idea: Talkin' Smack to Jar Jar
Bad Idea: Talkin' Smack to Crix Madine  

[FrozenPhoenix32]

GI: Kissing Leia
BI: Kissing your sister.  

[Darkened Angel]

Good idea: Leia captured by Jabba and forced to wear a metal bikini.
Bad idea: Having her get rescued and not wear it any more, but instead, some unattractive crap that nobody wants her in.  

[elvisnake]

Good idea: OT
Bad idea: PT
(This might have been taken before, I didn't look)  

[Nelowulf]

((more than likely))

Good Idea: Coming up with new characters and storylines.

Bad Idea: Using the same characters in storylines, making the galaxy seem like a disneyland ride gone wrong with the words, "Its a small galaxy after all..."  

[NickCpointless]

Good Idea:removeing jar jar for ep 2 and 3

Bad Idea:replaceing him with Golum "precious Force"  

[Darkened Angel]

Good Idea: Star Wars: A New Hope, The Empire Strikes Back, Return of the Jedi
Bad Idea: Lord of the Force: The Fellowship of the Jedi, The Two Death Stars, Return of the Emperor