Half Blood Prince Discussion (Spoilers like WOAH)

[skeledragon]

I loved HBP but i still can't belive it!! Why dumbledore??? Couldn't it of been draco or something!!! HBP was really dark..... and it gave out alot of info that i needed to fill in the blank spaces about voldermorts past and thos horcrux things.... biggrin  

[windy_star]

avada kedavra doesn't through ppl of a ledge dere4 dumbledore isn't dead and hagrid might b hiding him ok if ne1 wants 2 kill me say da word bang  

[xxScribbles]

windy_star

avada kedavra doesn't through ppl of a ledge dere4 dumbledore isn't dead and hagrid might b hiding him ok if ne1 wants 2 kill me say da word bang

BANG


-.-;

Use some proper English please. And know what you're talking about! The force of the spell threw him off the top of the tower. And if the spell didn't kill him (which wouldn't be possible if it was Avada Kedavra) the fall did. And Hagrid (no offence to Hagrid lovers) is a not exactly that great at hiding secrets...*cough Fluffy cough* and he would have spilled the beans by now most likely. crying  

[Awkward Biscuit]

I personally think Dumbledore IS dead. It makes me want to cry, but I think its true. He has been Harry's pillar for a while and I think its time for Harry to stand out on his own. But for those of you who think Dumbledore is still alive, there are some great reasons why at www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com
I don't own the site by the way.
*bursts into tears from disscussing dumbldores death for more than two seconds*  

[Fyyera]

i think dumbledore is dead,( crying ) but if hes not, he wont show up till the end of the 7th book. Jo killed him and sirius off because she wanted harry to do it on his own. i think snape is good, theres just too many clues, and i read the dumbledore isnt dead thing. ...but u know what a scary thought is? the very last word in the very last chapter on the VERY L-A-S-T page of book 7 is "scar". god i hate endings!! crying crying crying  

[mscarrieb]

ElvenPrincess977

I thought that it was a very good book one of the best in the series. I hate snape ******** basterd!! evil

i know, i believe hes evil too evil .  

[phoenix2storm]

slughorn is an pain in the rectum if you know what i mean  

[sparky102]

it was good adventures in it but i can't belive that dumbledore died! crying  

[rty677]

Magenta Platypus

I know! I never would've guess Snape would do that! mad

read the 7th book dumbledore tells him to cause the curse in his hand would have killed him and he wanted snape to take the elder wand but he didnt and voldmort kills snape.  

[rty677]

Fyyera

i think dumbledore is dead,( crying ) but if hes not, he wont show up till the end of the 7th book. Jo killed him and sirius off because she wanted harry to do it on his own. i think snape is good, theres just too many clues, and i read the dumbledore isnt dead thing. ...but u know what a scary thought is? the very last word in the very last chapter on the VERY L-A-S-T page of book 7 is "scar". god i hate endings!! crying crying crying

dont worry dumeldore tells snape to he is good and he also loved lilly that is why voldemort was going to spare her but she would not let go of harry>