What did you think...? *spoiler free zone*

[Lindini]

i really DON'T KNOW! i think i liked it, but i'm gonna have to do a re-read ASAP because my mom needed to take the book two days after i got it.. so i was reading like a madwoman! all through the night, three hours of sleep, then again straight after. suffice it to say, i probably don't remember enough of it to make an honest review sweatdrop but from what i remember, it was good. very clean ending, someone should have died, but satisfying.

oh, and i don't think they were OOC - it was just a side of the characters we hadn't seen. they were forced to grow up in ways they never had before, so of course they're going to seem a bit off. i can't imagine the stress of the situation!  

[Koneko Tsukino]

XX__MiSSES BRiGHTSIDE

Meh...
It was like one big a** fanfiction.
It certainly was a disappointment for me...
But there are still good things about the book.
Like Seth. <3
And it was a happy ending like I wanted...
I'm neutral on this.
She could have done better, but there also could have been worse.

exactly!
I liked a lot of it, and some of it seemed highl fanfictonay.
Switzerland, anyone?
Honestly, I can see why so many people were disappointed, but I truly enjoyed it. Like I said, there were highs and lows. I don't think SM lost her mind. She took her where she thought her characters wanted it to go. Sure, I could have done with a SWEET FIGHT SCENE at the end, but, meh, maybe there is one to come in the future.


I can't WAIT for Midnight Sun. I think it will be the redeeming point for a lot of people.