Welcome to Gaia! ::

Gaian Grammar Guild

Back to Guilds

The Gaian Grammar Guild is a refuge for the literate, a place for them to post and read posts without worrying about the nonsensical ones. 

Tags: grammar, literate, english, language 

Reply Gaian Grammar Guild
The Snobbery Misconception? Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Do you think the connection between grammar and snobbery exists?
  Yes!
  No!
  No comment!
View Results

MadnessFreak

PostPosted: Thu Mar 15, 2007 12:50 pm


SilverBellsAbove
I agree. No matter what you do, you cannot eliminate porn. But I wish that it was advertised a bit more blatantly...

I clicked on a link to 'Literates only: Tolkien' and got hobbit smut by mistake. Ugh. While it was funny, I thought they could have said 'adult roleplay' or something along those lines. It boggles the mind, I say.

I resisted the temptation to laugh at that.
PostPosted: Mon Mar 19, 2007 5:33 pm


-Swamp Sparrow-
I think it's due to persistent stereotypes. Look at media representations of people. The "intelligent", rich, and powerful usually have British or at least European accents, while people that are considered stupid have poor gramar and a Southern accent. We've actually been looking at this in my White Trash Fiction and Dirty Realism course at school. It's fascinating to look at these representations in literature.


I always thought the accent thing was a Hollywood development, intended to make it easier to tell the difference between character types. On the other hand, it's always fun to see the look on someone's face do a complete one-eighty when several minutes into a conversation they discover you're from the South. Intelligent speech means nothing; it's like they're watching you grow buck teeth, a third eye, and a speaker imbedded in your hunchback that broadcasts "Duelling Banjos" (good song, by the way) right before their eyes.

"White Trash Fiction"....? Whaaaat????

Setsu-P has stepped out


Ame Yuki Kaze

Clean Seeker

4,100 Points
  • Hygienic 200
  • Wall Street 200
  • Signature Look 250
PostPosted: Mon Mar 19, 2007 5:44 pm


I think there's definitely a stereotype against those who use proper English. If you use proper English, you're a rich, white, intellectual snob. I think this is why mediocrity and even out and out stupidity are favored in the mass media, whereas proper grammar is eschewed. When was the last time you heard a news caster speak in absolutely proper grammar? I never do.

It's sad, but that's what happens when you have an intellectual minority up against a mediocre majority.
User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.
PostPosted: Mon Mar 19, 2007 8:29 pm


There's nothing "snobbish" about speaking proper English. While we chose to actually construct sentences correctly and make sense, that doesn't make us snobby. It means that we don't want to be percieved as complete idiots.

HERO Lissuh


Lady Dracor

PostPosted: Mon Mar 19, 2007 8:41 pm


Well, for scholars, language is indeed a form of snobbery, but more specifically, a form of eliteness. The more esoteric, the longer a word is, the more points they feel they receive because a smaller and smaller audience is able to even begin to comprehend their writing even with the air of a non-abridged dictionary.

However, for a generally good vocabularly, generally I don't see snobbery associated with it. However, that may be in part because I do have a good vocabulary. I've found it annoys those who do not have quite the vocabulary. After all, on one really wants to ask someone what a word means in the middle of a friendly conversation.
PostPosted: Wed Mar 21, 2007 7:28 am


Proper speech isn't always linked to snobbery; neither is proper grammar. Simply put that we literates don't escape the clutches of stereotypes, and are classified as, "The bastards who won't let a single spelling error escape their overly sensitive ears". xd
We all know that being literate doesn't mean we're snobby, it just means we make an effort to type out a full, proper, English sentence.

SilverMaple

Sparkly Lover


-l- Eli -l-

PostPosted: Wed Mar 21, 2007 6:37 pm


ebandy
There's nothing "snobbish" about speaking proper English. While we chose to actually construct sentences correctly and make sense, that doesn't make us snobby. It means that we don't want to be percieved as complete idiots.


Sooo... people who don't choose to construct sentences correctly are idiots? sweatdrop

No offense, but you might wanna double check yourself for snobbery...
PostPosted: Wed Mar 21, 2007 9:11 pm


I think it is due to the fact that having a command of the proper usage of the language makes one appear more educated, and perhaps even refined (depending on vocabulary), and people associate these qualities with social class: the more proper you are, the more they may assume that you are from a higher class. Also, at least as far as when correcting someone's grammar, people take it personal in many cases, so they see that as being snobbish, too, which is unfortunate because proper grammar is important. I, however, do not associate the two. And cheers to you for being so graceful when being corrected. smile

splashseal

Fluffy Bunny

19,225 Points
  • Little Bunny Foo Foo 100
  • Pet Lover 100
  • Gifting Gone Wild 250

SonarP

PostPosted: Thu Mar 22, 2007 9:19 am


I think there are some links between literacy and the snobbiness of people.
However, I happen to go to a "rich, rural" school. If our school had a nickname, it would be Hollister High. But, check this out: A good percentage of people at my school can't spell, or know what "basic words" mean. I'm looked at for my "insanity"; my social skills aren't very good, but come English, or any other class, I'm smart as a whip. The freshmen have Hummers while the seniors have Expeditions and the like, but they can't figure out what the word "scarcity" means, which makes my inner chibi cry. I look at their papers, and my "red pen-dar" goes off like crazy.
It's funny that even people of my own race hate me because I haven't fallen into their "ghettofabulous" trap. I'm African-American, but I look at my brothers and sisters.............................if you can call them that, and I feel that this generation is doomed. They're not spending enough time reading "books" rather than just "i, u, h8t" text messages. Then again, reading is a big center in my family; my grandmother retired this year from teaching, and my parents...each of them have big bookcases..it's a library that I can go in there as I see fit and take what I want to read ('course I gotta ask..).
How can I put it? Being rich=/=being literate sometimes. Now, don't get me wrong, the things we have in this generation are nice. Ipods, cellphones...but do you think that this generation has taken the amusement out of reading for pleasure? Have we become to reliant on machines to fix our mistakes?
PostPosted: Fri Mar 23, 2007 11:06 am


SonarP
I think there are some links between literacy and the snobbiness of people.
However, I happen to go to a "rich, rural" school. If our school had a nickname, it would be Hollister High. But, check this out: A good percentage of people at my school can't spell, or know what "basic words" mean. I'm looked at for my "insanity"; my social skills aren't very good, but come English, or any other class, I'm smart as a whip. The freshmen have Hummers while the seniors have Expeditions and the like, but they can't figure out what the word "scarcity" means, which makes my inner chibi cry. I look at their papers, and my "red pen-dar" goes off like crazy.
It's funny that even people of my own race hate me because I haven't fallen into their "ghettofabulous" trap. I'm African-American, but I look at my brothers and sisters.............................if you can call them that, and I feel that this generation is doomed. They're not spending enough time reading "books" rather than just "i, u, h8t" text messages. Then again, reading is a big center in my family; my grandmother retired this year from teaching, and my parents...each of them have big bookcases..it's a library that I can go in there as I see fit and take what I want to read ('course I gotta ask..).
How can I put it? Being rich=/=being literate sometimes. Now, don't get me wrong, the things we have in this generation are nice. Ipods, cellphones...but do you think that this generation has taken the amusement out of reading for pleasure? Have we become to reliant on machines to fix our mistakes?


So true, mate. Although I occasionally read, I still can speak in near-perfect sentences. It's my vocabulary that I'm lacking in, though.

Natsuri


Akira Valdis

PostPosted: Sat Mar 24, 2007 7:33 pm


MadnessFreak
SilverBellsAbove
I agree. No matter what you do, you cannot eliminate porn. But I wish that it was advertised a bit more blatantly...

I clicked on a link to 'Literates only: Tolkien' and got hobbit smut by mistake. Ugh. While it was funny, I thought they could have said 'adult roleplay' or something along those lines. It boggles the mind, I say.

I resisted the temptation to laugh at that.

*Laughs* As you can see...I didn't. And that's pretty gross, but I see your point. Say what it is, for crying out loud. Anyhoo...

I think the link between being literate and being snobby is idiots being jealous. I know sometimes I'll just use a "big word", and around most of my friends, who are all a bit older than me, it's fine. Normally, I'm the one asking them to kindly define various things. But if I do that around some of my, say jock friends (not being rude to jocks, I'm sometimes one and I know many very intelligent jocks...) but still. They yell at me for using big words and tell me to shut up. In my opinion, that's being very rude. What can I say? I enjoy using a variety of words. I think it gets boring to use the same thing repeatedly. Anyway...my thoughts on the matter. Farewell.
PostPosted: Sat Mar 24, 2007 7:38 pm


Something I forgot to mention. About the "literates only" thing at the beginning of this thread...I agree that people who block others out immediately because they're 'not good enough' is very snobby, but when I role play with some of my friends on gaia, they normally put 'mostly literate', or 'good literacy please' in the title. That I can understand because they prefer a storyline that makes sense and is readable; I try not to think of that as being snobby, just a request and it's something people can strive for.

That hardly made any sense at all, did it? ...didn't think so. I need caffinated tea.

Akira Valdis


PsYcHoSyS

7,850 Points
  • Prayer Circle 200
  • Mark Twain 100
  • Megathread 100
PostPosted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 4:00 pm


chiyojo
ebandy
There's nothing "snobbish" about speaking proper English. While we chose to actually construct sentences correctly and make sense, that doesn't make us snobby. It means that we don't want to be percieved as complete idiots.


Sooo... people who don't choose to construct sentences correctly are idiots? sweatdrop

No offense, but you might wanna double check yourself for snobbery...


It's a choice, right? Why would people who know how to construct a sentence correctly choose not to? To fit in with the popular crowds? I really don't get it.
PostPosted: Tue Apr 10, 2007 3:42 pm


Rich people at my school think that since they're so rich, they can slack at language.
I have a bad habit of atutomatically correcting people.....
And the way they glared at me when I corrected them...
*grabs a DeathNote and scrawls their names in*
I hate snobby people...
Show me one, and they will LITERALLY get their *beep* kicked.

[Joan De Arc]


Carpe Omnium

Sparkly Lunatic

10,400 Points
  • Angelic Alliance 100
  • Divorced 100
  • Vanquished Angel 50
PostPosted: Tue Apr 10, 2007 10:59 pm


I personally don't see the connection; just because I can speak properly doesn't make me a "snob". People sometimes deride me for the way I choose to speak, but I just think to myself: "At least I'm coherent".
It isn't high-and-mighty to use good grammar; it just means you give a damn about how you come across, and wish to be understood.
Reply
Gaian Grammar Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum