Edward VS. Jacob

[Scandalous bb]

Edward, because he loves her so much that he would risk his own happiness just to keep her safe  

[vampirephantom27]

I see Jacob more as a brother figure. and it's Edward ALL THE WAY. Edward was willing to end it to keep her safe. To me, Edward would do anything for Bella. It doesn't matter that he broke her heart cause their together now anyhow. besides he proposed. we'll see how that turns out in Eclipse.  

[xAlyss The Pirate]

vampirephantom27

I see Jacob more as a brother figure. and it's Edward ALL THE WAY. Edward was willing to end it to keep her safe. To me, Edward would do anything for Bella. It doesn't matter that he broke her heart cause their together now anyhow. besides he proposed. we'll see how that turns out in Eclipse.

Yeah I agree
I wonder if Bella and Edward will get married.  

[Kagura+kyo]

EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!! EDWARD!!!
I don't really like Jacob. I agree with what everyone who said Edward said.  

[Moonlite Romance]

screw jacob.....EDWARD! oh, and todays his b-day! 6/20!!!  

[Pestanas Bonitas]

Jacob dammit!
D:<
not for Bella though
for moi, as my favorite of the two
: )
i think he's sweeter and more happier
>o<
and i thank Stephenie for giving him a HUGE part
WEREWOLVES FTW
'sides, he's humongous
i like big guys
i'm not one for the pale kind
i like dark, tall, sweet guys
if only he had kept his long hair
damn
what was the purpose of chopping off his hair?
:/

 

[misohead]

edward xd

die jacob burning_eyes  

[pearlized]

Edward of course. heart heart

Jacob.. well, I feel bad for him. so I hope he falls in love with someone else. so that way he can be happy. But Edward & Bella totally belong together.  

[pearlized]

stardust006

EDWARD EDWARD EDWARD! I don't think Jacob could truelly and really ever be her best friend. Even if Edward (god forbid) "killed" himself, I don't think they would be good friends. Jacob's whole werewolf thing would get in the way and he possibly could hurt her more then Edward.

I disagree. Jacob would never hurt Bella. Don't forget that Edward wants to eat her too.  

[Edward Cullen is My Life]

pearlized

stardust006

EDWARD EDWARD EDWARD! I don't think Jacob could truelly and really ever be her best friend. Even if Edward (god forbid) "killed" himself, I don't think they would be good friends. Jacob's whole werewolf thing would get in the way and he possibly could hurt her more then Edward.

I disagree. Jacob would never hurt Bella. Don't forget that Edward wants to eat her too.

but he fights the temptation of drinking her blood every single day!!!
AND he sucked out the venom from james when he bit her WITHOUT killing her!!!!
i believe that the only time that he WOULD bite her is WHEN *not if* he changes her!!!

EDWARD ANTHONY MASEN CULLEN!!!!!!
heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart  

[Fifii]

jacob is still a great guy, he just isn't a quitter  

[ToxiCookie]

Edward all the way heart Jacobs a great guy but he's also can act really mean like calling them all bloodsuckers WTF! scream That made me really mad SO JACOB CAN DIE burning_eyes 4laugh Edward is the best 4 any1  

[Ginakage]

Well, I agree that Jacob is really more of a brother figure for Bella but he really does care for her alot more. And, he wouldn't hurt Bella and Edward wouldn't hurt Bella. But, he did call the Cullens "bloodsuckers" and he is a werewolf... and Edward did propose to her and promise to change her into a vampire, but he has broken promises to her before. For example, he did say that he would make it seem as if he were never there when it was really killing her inside and made her lose a friend and her father's trust... sort of. Hmm... I really don't know who to choose. I liked Jake better in Twilight than in New Moon 'cause he was younger and smexier than in New Moon when he got too tall and hacked off all his awesome hair. But Edward was always there for her until he thought it was best that he left to keep her safe; which actually really did almost kill her when she decided to jump off the cliff just to hear his voice. And Jake did save her from that. And Edward did end up coming back for her... so I choose...

IDK!  

[hiwhatsup195]

I like Edward the best. Even though Jacob is nice, he just doesn't seem like A boyfriend type for Bella. And Edward really never broke promises he just thought that if he left it would be safer for Bella. Which, obviously we learn it's a bad idea, but he didn't know that.  

[hiwhatsup195]

Ginakage Uchiha

Well, I agree that Jacob is really more of a brother figure for Bella but he really does care for her alot more. And, he wouldn't hurt Bella and Edward wouldn't hurt Bella. But, he did call the Cullens "bloodsuckers" and he is a werewolf... and Edward did propose to her and promise to change her into a vampire, but he has broken promises to her before. For example, he did say that he would make it seem as if he were never there when it was really killing her inside and made her lose a friend and her father's trust... sort of. Hmm... I really don't know who to choose. I liked Jake better in Twilight than in New Moon 'cause he was younger and smexier than in New Moon when he got too tall and hacked off all his awesome hair. But Edward was always there for her until he thought it was best that he left to keep her safe; which actually really did almost kill her when she decided to jump off the cliff just to hear his voice. And Jake did save her from that. And Edward did end up coming back for her... so I choose...

IDK!

Edward can't break his promise though for changing her. In the book the Volturi(sp?) said they would check up on her. Even if it is 30 years from then, eventually he will have to change her if he doesn't want her to be killed.