Emmett or Edward??? Eh???

[Aurora Tate]

I don't know. Tis one is pretty tough. Although Emmett could kick Edwrd's a** with brute strength alone Edward has speed and stratagy on his side. Emmett doesn't think through his move and just relys on his strength and Edward is very calculating. I'd say it would end with both of them knocking the snot out of each other and nobody truly winning. It's to evenly matched.  

[Jasper Hales love]

Fifii

not at all, my man Emmett would whoop edward, he'd take him down to china town.

oohhhhhh yeah!!!!  

[Fifii]

that's right and i will stand behind my opinion till the end, Emmett would whoop Edward  

[Jasper Hales love]

areed but Jasper can beat emmett so would he beat Edward it sais in Midnight Sun the first chapter emmett was mad he lost to Jasper  

[Fifii]

yeah i read that too.  

[niecerpiecer]

Me 3 4laugh I think Emmett would win though srry Edward  

[the1orlylover]

emmit may be strong but edward is the fastest plus jasper would calm them down !!!!  

[Keume-chan]

well i think emmett is tougher but i still like edward better!!!  

[dibbo4793]

edward. emmetf is ok, but edward rules all.  

[GreenEyedKatt]

i think it would depend on the reason if edward was mad enough i think he could take him out like if for some reason he was gonna hurt bella in a way he could probobly beat emmet  

[Addicted2Strbucks]

I think emmett would win!  

[AerialCaptain]

It really depends on Edward. If he uses his gift then he'll probably win due to the fact
he will know what Emmett will do next. But Emmett could still manage it ^^ Im all for Emmett Woot!  

[Fifii]

still say my guy emmett would win  

[purple_pirate_lover]

That would be tough but in New Moon when they did the training Jasper was able to beat Emment without being able to read his mind, so i would have to say Edward smile  

[Loveless in the Twilight]

Fifii

not at all, my man Emmett would whoop edward, he'd take him down to china town.

Yeah. No contst.