Jacob or Edward?

[[ M!DNIGHT ]]

Haru Minatsuki

Fifii

i prefer both of them shirtless and kissing

I agree, totally!

ditto... maybe we can petition Stephanie to create a 'what if' side book for us...  

[Sakura_Angel_Tears]

-NolaGirlAtHeart-

So one day in Science class me and my friends brought up this topic.
I personally dont like jacob. He seems like an arrogant fool who cant face the facts that bella will never be his.
I love Edward. He seems like my dream guy. But a little overreactive. Which is obvious in New Moon and Eclispe.

My whole purpose is;
Who would you rather? And why?

EDWARD!
Because......EDWARD!!! xd

 

[blondestickergluer]

i like Edward....i dont think words can describe him....hes perfect...i mean wouldnt you wanna kiss those icy cold marble lips? I WOULD! biggrin  

[bigsisate]

Edward all the way. I know he left Bella but he did it because he thought it was the right thing for her. I understand his reasoning but he should have at least kept a close eye on her. His heart was in the right place but his decision was very wrong. Jacob sounds like a nice guy in the book, but he doesn't really sound like my type.  

[xXgoth_girl12Xx]

Edward-sama, of course.
I have nothing against Jacob-tachi, of course, but Edward-sama i just like better.  

[XFLASH_glamourx]

hmmm...

I think i would have to go with Edward. He's more mature and... mysterious. And he sounds like a total dreamboat! heart

But Jacob is cute. 3nodding  

[LexiLu Latte]

EDWARD! he is perfect in every way! hes beautiful in mind and soul, he is a vampire! hello and he is just absolutely *dazzling* as twilight would say
Jacob needs to go away! he doesn't get bella, he dosen't need bella, he wont get bells, and he better not get bells. he needs to back off. i don't want Edward and bella ruined because of him. Jacob and bells don't belong together, well maybe if there was no Edward but there is ! and she needs him like she needs her brain, couldn't say oxygen or heart cause soon enough she wont need those! but she is really in love with Edward. she and Jacob would have never gotten close if it weren't for Edward.i cant believe bella actually thinks she loves that dog as a human soul mate! JACOB NEEDS TO BACK OFF!
I LOVE EDWARD FOREVER!  

[purple_pirate_lover]

Lyxsing

Personally, I can't stand Jacob. He's too...forward. Bella just wants to be friends, and he forces himself on her. Even when she later realizes she loves him, she wouldn't have realized that if he hadn't been so kissy.

I agree completely. I have to go for edward! heart  

[Wolves_Witches_and_Love]

Personally i would have to say.........Edward! Who else? I love edward. he's my dream guy.

I like Jacob but to me he's too much of a fool. She doesn't love him. I love how she punched him and how Edward was like speeding over to her.

For me it's a no brainer. I love Edward and cried when he left Bella.  

[Aquaura]

I think both are awesome blaugh  

[CalmWinds]

Quote:

I prefer Jake, he's kind, warm and sweet. I don't hate edward but he gets on my nerves, being so overprotective, bossy and irrational. Jakes irrational at times as well, but I like him more.

Go Team Jake!

I soo agree!

I pick Jacob. Edward is very overprotective and bossy. And when Edward left her, and then came back.. it made me so mad that Bella just forgave him like that. She wasn't even mad. After reading the first three books, I think Bella should be with Jacob.
And at the end of Eclipse.. it made me cry.

I just want.. Bella to be with Jacob. .. ;l  

[alisonlynn]

Jacob!!!!!! Jacobjacobjacobjacobjacobjacob!!!!!!!!

I think they should be together because Edward is dead, cold, and, if she chose him, Bella would have to eat penquins. Plus, almost everything I want from my life, Bella could have with Jacob. She couldn't have that with Edward. And she loves him.

Edward is like a drug. Jacob is like the sun. I, personally, would choose a sun over a drug anyday.

Edward can be cloned so all of his many fans can have a copy. Bella gets Jacob.  

[Maquela928]

Personally Jacob gets on my nerves a lot, and he is a little bit to young for Bella.
But Edward on the other hand is her age, and he is like a cross between an abercrombie model and a vampire god! I wonder what Edward what really look like in real life, oh my god I think I would faint! xD  

[Fifii]

edward  

[Ehclipse Mint]

To be honest. I don't know who to choose anymore. I love Edward, yet I can't get rid of Jacob...it's too hard to decide. For now I'll just say both.