which actor best fit their character?

[RejectedLimpet]

Best:

Carlisle blaugh
Esme blaugh
Alice blaugh
Billy (Jacob's Dad) 3nodding
Rosalie 3nodding
Jessica smile
Charlie (Bella's Dad) smile
Jasper eek
Edward eek
Jacob neutral
Mike neutral
Eric stare
Angela talk2hand
Seth talk2hand
Bella emo

To be honest, Rob surprised me. As soon as i saw who was cast as Edward, i wanted to go and strangle somebody. I honestly didn't think he could do the part. He definately didn't look like the Edward that i had imagined. But i guess that's what is so unique about books. Only you can imagine who's who and if theyr'e going to make the book a film, they cna't always get it right.
But i was deeply disapointed with Kristen Stewart. She made everything look so hard. She didn't have the nice bubbly Bella-ness in her acting. She kind of looked how i imagined Bella but her acting was poor, and that's what ruined it for me. The meadow scene was awful.

And i didn't imagine Seth to look so.. Indian-like? I knew they were hippy-ish but still... talk2hand
Oh, and i thought that Jacob's hair was supposed to be.. shoulder-legnth, and up in a ponytail? Not long enough to reach his elbows.

 

[Aradia Helevorn]

RejectedLimpet

To be honest, Rob surprised me. As soon as i saw who was cast as Edward, i wanted to go and strangle somebody. I honestly didn't think he could do the part. He definately didn't look like the Edward that i had imagined. But i guess that's what is so unique about books. Only you can imagine who's who and if theyr'e going to make the book a film, they cna't always get it right.
But i was deeply disapointed with Kristen Stewart. She made everything look so hard. She didn't have the nice bubbly Bella-ness in her acting. She kind of looked how i imagined Bella but her acting was poor, and that's what ruined it for me. The meadow scene was awful.

I totally agree! i mean when i first heard the cast i wanted to scream at something. how could they do that to such a great book? all these no names that pry didn't know what they were doing and the two main ones with no acting skills at all. well i was surprised with Robert, very, very surprised. Kristen i hoped would have gotten better but indeed she hadn't. I agree with everything you said quoated above!  

[RejectedLimpet]

Aradia Helevorn

I totally agree! i mean when i first heard the cast i wanted to scream at something. how could they do that to such a great book? all these no names that pry didn't know what they were doing and the two main ones with no acting skills at all. well i was surprised with Robert, very, very surprised. Kristen i hoped would have gotten better but indeed she hadn't. I agree with everything you said quoated above!

Yeah! I know what you mean!
I was SO annoyed with the meadow scene though. And i know it's a film, but they hadn't really stuck to the script from the book. I'm pleased they got the Lion And The Lamb quote in. But they missed out LOADS of good scenes. We should've had mroe of Edward in Bella's room at night and them both in their classes at school. Although, they portrayed the baseball scene VERY well. That's my ultimate favourite scene in the film. And the music made it so much better, Supermassive Black Hole - Muse. 4laugh

Edit:Well.. Ok, i'll be fair. I had just finished re-reading Twilight the night before i saw the film. So i was a bit more of a critic when i saw the film than i would normally have been... But still... burning_eyes

 

[Aradia Helevorn]

Oh thats fine with me. i'm always a terrible critic when i see movies. i'm just one of those people who really apreciates the details of a novel and it bothers me when important things are taken out. my biggest peeve is actually the fact that they took out carlisle and alice"s stories. thats major character profiling they took out! but indeed the baseball scene was my favorite. i'll never look at the sport the same again. lol. not that i really liked it much to begin with. I think they focused more on their physical relationship than their emotional one which sux. there's just so much more to it. >_<  

[covo]

Alice and Carlisle were the closest in my opinion but everyone else was also pretty good. Overall, it was great casting.  

[Etzlenos Belliveau]

For me :-

Alice - best-looking..exactly how I pictured her.
Jasper - He's a little too stiff..but I still like Jackson Rathbone.
Carlisle - I thought he would look a little younger like what the book says.
Esme - She looked older than I thought.
Edward - He's okay..Except for the sparkly part.
Bella - She's a good Bella.
Emmett - I had always like Kellan Lutz. So, I would consider this perfect.
Rosalie - She's not the "most beautiful" character in my opinion.
Jacob - He's looks handsome without the long hair.
Charlie - He's a perfect dad.. biggrin
Billy - He looks so different from Jacob..but it was alright.
Mike - He's really cute..
Tyler - I didn't expect him to be black. But he's cool.
Eric - If he was a little taller, I would like him.  

[Myakachii]

I loved Jasper, Alice, Carlisle, and Rosalie. I think they all fit their character perfectly. At first, Edward sounded a little awkward, but he got better as the movie progressed...

Another thing about Edward was that when he's in the forest, and he's showing her what he can do and stuff, when he said, "As if I need it!" I always imagined him kind of laughing, but in the movie, he sounded all mad and stuff. D:

But Alice was my number one favorite. <3 I love how she was always dancing around, and Jasper just stands there looking all serious. Or, "O_O"

And... Charlie, when I imagined him, he was always balding. xd But, Stephanie wrote the book, she made the characters, so I think she knows what they should look like, better than we do. ^_^;;;

At my school, Eric is everyone's favorite, just because he's so random. "IT'S LAH POOSH, BABEH." xd And Mike, when he's dancing outside the window.

When I went to the movie, I thought that Edward would be my favorite guy. Nope. It was Carlisle. xd He was pretty.

Bella, I was disappointed with. D:

And the end was wonderful. biggrin Except, I felt bad for Victoria. D;  

[NorthEastFire]

I think Alice and Esme were the best for their characters. Oh, and Charlie.  

[IntotheDestiny]

I thought that Jasper, Alice, Rosalie, Emmett, Charile (can't forget about good old Charile), and Bella's friends along with Billy Black were awesome.

The girl who played Bella: not so much
Robert Patterson: He did a good job but I didn't see him as Edward.
Carlisle: O_o I thought he was going to look a bit different than that but I liked it.
Esme: >_< I thought she was going to have a more motherly look.
Jacob: Poor Taylor....has the skin tone and the body but not the actual features of the character Jacob. I didn't like it at all.  

[Gilded Crows]

kristen stewart looked the part, but she cant act for s**t and it annoyed me to no end. robert pattinson looked really close to what i pictured edward like. i liked alice too, but her voice seemed..off. carlisle didnt look anything near what i saw him as, emse was good, rosalie wasnt pretty enough, emmett....there was just something wrong about him idk what. i think his face maybe. jasper fit perfectly, excpet for his hair burning_eyes and i really liked charlie's casting too  

[_-Mitsubachi-_-Fujin-_]

I think Rob might have been too focused on imitating an american accent to hide his english accent.... which was annoying for the movie. At least that is what I felt was one of the problems with him.

 

[pink_sushi15]

probably carlisle or emmet!