Welcome to Gaia! ::

Now who's spouting bull? Kakashi himself said that the jutsu was only a manipulation of charka shape, not it's nature. He even stated that that is what made it an incomplete jutsu, as the 4th died before finishing it. You're saying it's wind just on the basis that it LOOKS like it's made of wind.

Not every jutsu has an element, the regular bushin has no element for example, neither does any summoning jutsu. What about that underground decapitation jutsu Kakashi used in the very beginning of the series against Sasuke? I had nothjing to do with ground just because he was hiding in the ground.

Also, you're wrong about the affinities. They never once stated that the affinity gave yoiu control of that element, merely that you were disposed to jutsus of those type and that your charka flows different than other affinities. Affinity does not equal control of. Sure, if Naruto made a wind jutsu that made wind blades to cut people up he could do that. But that would not be full control of an element, that would be a jutsu. Otherwise I could make the claim that since Kakashi is lighting affinity, that he should be able to make lighting come from nowhere without moving and inch or doing a single hand seal.

This isn't Avatar and this isn't x-men, there is no pyro, iceman, storm or any other elemental controllers. This is Naruto, it's a bit different over here.

Or is this one of those cases where you're one of those people who think that you know more than the writer himself? Because I've met people like that who thought they knew more about star wars than ******** George Lucas himself. Let me tell you, not a pretty sight.