Lightsaber Lucas

[NickCpointless]

the only problem i had with episode 3 was padme dieing in ROTJ she says she remmembers her yet she had just been born when she died i mean who remmembers anything when their born and even so why wouldnt luke he was born first that was the only thing that pissed me off








well that and the poor fighting of grievous  

[Sol Walker]

Blame Lucas.
the damn hack.  

[Storm TK421]

Cale Darksun

Blame Lucas.
the damn hack.

eek He wasnt a Hack in the 70s....when he made the movies. cool  

[Shinn Matsunaga]

No, in the seventies he could write.
Then when the eighties hit all the suck attacked at once.  

[Mitth_raw_nuruodo]

I throw my nomination to Tenel Ka for Miss GFFA.

Can't really think of anyone else at the moment though.  

[Sol Walker]

man, we really need to set that up.
Maybe this weekend eh?  

[FrozenPhoenix32]

lol. We're lazy.  

[Storm TK421]

men rolleyes  

[Sol Walker]

Meh what?  

[Des Voh]

~:sits around listening to the others and sips coffee:~mmmmmm>_<

 

[Millennium_Pharaoh_Nakia]

Crossman

I'm sure someone has already mentioned this, but my biggest issue with the prequels is the timeline! It completely goes against everything. Episode III, according to the movies, is only like 18-20 years before Episode IV. The clones wars were supposed to have been at least 30-40 years prior. And Anakin was not even supposed to become Vader until AFTER the clone wars. YEARS after. The Official Guide to the Star Wars Universe, from back in the 90s has all the basic events dated. This was something approved by Lucas! The time inconsistancies are horrible!!!

And don;t even get me started on the time jumps in Ep. III like Palpatine being able to race across the galaxy from Coruscant to Mustafar instantly after the battle between Anakin and Obi-Wan.

It was just ALL poorly and planned and horrifically executed.

George Lucas should be linched and then the prequels remade, CORRECTLY.

Ok, while I have my own issues with the SW prequels, a point about the whole rescue thing: The fight between Yoda and Palpatine didn't necessarily last as long as the one between Obi-Wan and Anakin. I know it's cut like that, but my personal opinion is that Palpatine had just enough time to get there...plus the fact that Anakin caught on fire just as Obi-wan left, but the flames were out when Palpatine got there.


Perhaps part of the problem that Lucas had making the prequels is that he'd already approved timelines and story elements. Like a writer, such a story would undergo many revisions; unfortunately, when one version is accepted as set in stone, the newer one usually isn't accepted.  

[FrozenPhoenix32]

I don't remember the CW ever being dated precicely till the PT..  

[Sol Walker]

*sigh*
He fudged that up so badly....  

[Kizumo]

FrozenPhoenix32

KJA=idiot

George lucas must be sabred because: putting Jar Jar into DVD RoTJ and editting Hayden Christensen in..i liked the old dude better!

yea i didn't like how he changed the ghost ether  

[Kizumo]

i did'nt like how that some of the fighting didn't go on longer in E3 like i would liked to see mace and Anakin fight more