Edward VS. Jacob

[xAlyss The Pirate]

*Sort of Spoiler*

So have you read some of the stuff said about Eclipse? "She'll have to choose between friendship and love and between life and death" or something like that. But even if she has to choose I would still pick Edward. Jacob did a lot of things to help her, but Edward and her are just suppose to be. You can't just break up a love like that, over someone else. Although Jacob DOES deserve someone. And Bella should spend time with other friends, but I don't get why Edward refuses to let her go see Jake. I'm pretty sure he can handle his anger and won't hurt her. He wouldn't let anything happen to her.  

[xAlyss The Pirate]

Levina_Ellar

That's what I was thinking. To be honest, Bella is the one that kind of irritates me. Right when Edward returned, she forgot about Jacob. Even after all he's done for her! Like Charlie said, have some time for your other friends! Gosh seriously... stressed

Haha, I'm getting all worked up on a book.

Lol it's k. I get worked up over books too. Like in New Moon when Edward left I cried. D:
What? I was sad. And angry.  

[Fifii]

xXxWakeMeUpInsidexXx

*Sort of Spoiler*

So have you read some of the stuff said about Eclipse? "She'll have to choose between friendship and love and between life and death" or something like that. But even if she has to choose I would still pick Edward. Jacob did a lot of things to help her, but Edward and her are just suppose to be. You can't just break up a love like that, over someone else. Although Jacob DOES deserve someone. And Bella should spend time with other friends, but I don't get why Edward refuses to let her go see Jake. I'm pretty sure he can handle his anger and won't hurt her. He wouldn't let anything happen to her.

yeah but something could happen and because of bella's bad luck edward is not taking any chances. and you're right about edward and bella belonging together.  

[Her Sinful Fantasies]

-hides behind a wall affraid to be attacked by all the Edward lovers-

JACOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ninja  

[xAlyss The Pirate]

..+.Shadows-Kat.+..

-hides behind a wall affraid to be attacked by all the Edward lovers-

JACOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ninja

lol
i like yur avie. :]  

[niecerpiecer]

..+.Shadows-Kat.+..

-hides behind a wall affraid to be attacked by all the Edward lovers-

JACOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ninja

rofl Dont be afraid of them its ur opinoin besides Jacob is a great guy  

[red_angel14]

i heart edward!  

[misohead]

I HATE JACOB

I heart EDWARD  

[niecerpiecer]

misohead

I HATE JACOB

I heart EDWARD

huh w/e 2 me if u hate Jacob u hate Stepheines brother she named Jacob after him and Jacob is not selfish Bella wuz she even said so in the book duh!  

[xweetjasmine92]

I luv Edward more but Jacob is soo nice i feel about wat happens to him. BUT i'm still a edward fan all the way. Jacob just made the book boring to me. sweatdrop  

[niecerpiecer]

Yeah some parts of New Moon were boring like barely no danger as Twilight did 3nodding  

[Zirumi]

Jacobs a really nice person....its just....Edward is irrisistible. I felt bad for both sides when he left, though I really want to read how he felt after he got the call. So I'd say Edward, and I hope Jake and her somehow manage to stay friends. Though I think Jake got what was coming to him when he stayed so persistant, even though it was obvious what was going to happen if Edward came back stare  

[Reikage-Sanshi]

Fifii

Ayllin

Fifii

edward should be with bella, but jacob deserves her more

Hmm.. That's interesting. What makes you think that? Although I do agree, I want to hear your opinion.

well jacob didn't kill her on the inside, he let bella do things like ride a motorcyle, something edward would never let her do, and everytime jacob breaks a promise he says he's sorry, i can't recall edward every doing that

Actually.. it tore Edward apart when he couldn't be with Bella. I know some of yah are going to hate me.. but I do feel sorry for Jacob, and wish there was a kiss scene between Jacob and Bella... -giggles- cuz it would have been more interesting as in battling inner demons on who she would choose. Also it wouldn't hurt for Bella to have a few minutes of happiness; then again... it would have teared her up more when she saw Edward again.  

[night-owl123]

I hate Jacob. Of course Edward and Bella HAVE to be together, and Jacob was only a "friend", but he was trying to STEAL her! Even if he saved her in a way, NO ONE can compete with Edward. heart  

[night-owl123]

Fifii

edward should be with bella, but jacob deserves her more

I agree, but I still think Jacob is trying to steal her away from Edward.