Is Harry the Descendant oif Godric Gryffindor???????????

[Fleur Evette]

J.K Rowling said he wasn't.  

[HaaaaveYouMetTed]

no  

[thats-miss-FREAK-to-you]

it is a nice idea but i dont think so  

[The Love Turtle]

R J Lupin

I Know the part about the sorting hat. And I know about Slytherin. But Harry also according to the hat although it never said it He had the traits of a ravenclaw too.

Well, Ravenclaw's are smart, nae? Harrys smart because he knew that he had to speak parsel tounge to get into the chamber of secrets  

[loser224]

i don't think that harry's godri's descendint, no way  

[Sheena Ayame]

covo

@R J Lupin: You have made some really good points but I just don't believe that Harry is the heir. But if he is the heir, that would make a really good plot twist for the next book.

Agred. That would be quite the ironic twist. xd  

[loser224]

no he's not  

[Harlequin-Avarice]

Who knows? Maybe. You could definately make an argument for it.  

[TheArbitrator]

i dont think so. the only reason he was put in grffydor is cuz he gets into trouble. in terms ofmarks, hes average. so grffyndor it is and godric no  

[LoveSnivellus]

no... I dont think so... he only was sorted into Griifndor b/c he asked to... and he only pulled the sword from the hat b/c "he had courage" I highly doubt that he descended from Griffindor, because he would have had somesort of an heirloom or thing to prove for it, and they would have hinteda bout it by now.. not just plot it in the 7th book biggrin  

[Nicole Potter]

I do not think so. Otherwise, why was Harry almost put into Slytherin?  

[SinsOfTheDivine]

Because Harry and his parents lived in Godric’s Hollow, I think it's a pretty safe bet. But no one (exceot for J.K.R) knows for sure.

 

[tvkid2471]

in my opinion there is no way that harry is the decendant of griffindor but thats just my way of thinking  

[LoveSnivellus]

R J Lupin

This is what I think:

When he was sorted, he could have been put in Ravenclaw (not a bad mind) or Slytherin as the sorting hat had said. But instead it was gryffindor because Harry said not Slytherin. When Harry got out of the chamber after defeating Tom Riddle and the can't spell Baslisk or what ever it is. Dumbledore said only a true Gryffindor could have pulled that out of the hat. Maybe not someone from the school house but someone of Gryffindor blood. Harry lived in a town called Godrics Hallow. His father was in Gryffindor.
Godric and Salazaar fought and the fight was never finished. Now the heir of Slytherin will Finish the Filght with The Heir of Gryffindor.

thats pretty good... but I think that when Dumbledore said that only a true Gryffindor could pull out that sword, it meant that since Harry showed such loyalty to Dumbledore he was a ture Gryffindor... but other than that, your idea is pretty ligit XD  

[Remus_Lupin3]

Well, I agree with you Remus. He is definetly a desendent.