Tia Dalma or Elizabeth Swann?

[IdealPrspective]

Carnivorous Herbivore

Tia isn't Jack's mum. His mum is the shrunken head thing lol.

I reckon Tia is better than Elizabeth. Elizabeth is annoying, she kisses like every guy possible... Who hasn't she kissed? Davy Jones, that's it. Also Tia is the Calypso goddess thing. I just find how she speaks annoying...

exactly! i've always found Elizabeth to be annoying and like every guy likes her!  

[amakama]

I have a question:

Is Tia is Calypso right?
So why did she bring Barbossa back when she couldn't bring back Elizabeth's dad?

heres my theory. [spoilers]
She brought back Barbossa, cos then they could find Jack and becuase Jack had the 9th piece, they could set Calypso free,
so would that make Calypso evil?  

[wishy fishey]

Tia..But she does need to brush her teeth...=)  

[Selene Snape]

Tia Dalma she's awesome! She's a goddess and you know that she probally has done it with just about every pirate out on the sea! We know for a fact that her and Jack, she's a player! ((although she has crabs))  

[Nicole-Krisa]

I love Elizabeth! but I had to vote for Tia...

Tia is really cool. I like her apperence, and her speach!

Will is in love with liz and thinks she is awesome and I can't disagree with Will. Plus i love thier romance and support WE all the way! She is a part of that but still Tia is just too cool.  

[bigboyvincent101]

elizabeth cuz shes hot  

[Vlad_the_Vamp]

no one seems to be backing up ms. swann so i will. yea she chains jack to the mast but if you think about it she had to or else everyone would be dead  

[amakama]

DiNo FrEeZe PoP42

Tia..But she does need to brush her teeth...=)

blaugh I'd have to agree with you there...  

[Luckybug76]

Lol. yeah.

But I personally like Elziabeth. She can totally kick butt. May I remind you of the "I'm listening intently" scene? I was practically DYING I was laughing so hard when she had the gun at his head!!!  

[whycantyoudeletethistrash]

Blue Jay Sparrow

Lol. yeah.

But I personally like Elziabeth. She can totally kick butt. May I remind you of the "I'm listening intently" scene? I was practically DYING I was laughing so hard when she had the gun at his head!!!

 

[rockbunni13]

Elizabeth Swann!!  

[Punkiieee]

Elizabeth Swann

 

[Luckybug76]

Might I add that the only bummer with Lizzie is that EVERY MAN SHE KISSES IS KILLED IN A MATTER OF FIVE MINUTES OR LESS! *sniff* We lost four great men that way...two came back, two still dead....

But I still think Lizzie is cooler pirate  

[iLennon]

well elizabeth is in all the movies and tia doma dies kinda >-< and elizabeth has ill ^-^  

[Zelda76]

Tia Dalma biggrin

She's a very misteryous and loveable smile
Her house is very interesting.. smile

She's a witch, a good friend...cute 4laugh