Breaking Dawn Epic Fail petition

[Aqua Anjel]

Just thought I'd share this......

I was on youtube again and I was watching Touj0ursPur BD review #10 (recommended to watch reviews 1-9 under the username TechNBailey (same girl with NoMoreMarbles a.k.a Bailey))
And she posted a link to a Breaking Dawn fail petition. I know some people here LOVE BD so you don't have to look at the link, but I thought I'd share it with the people who

A.) have mixed feelings

or

B.) Hate the book. period.

I for one have come to the conclusion that BD was all wrong for the most part and we deserved better. While I still love Steph, I signed it. I don't want to bash Steph, that's just how I feel. And I didn't agree with all petions explainations, but It covered most of them.

BD Failed Petition  

[WineChan]

surprised

Well, I have a explaination for the question why Bella didn't act like a normal newborn.

She hated blood when she was a human.

Of course, turning into a vampire, she'd have to drink blood. But because she faints at the sight of it when she was human, isn't it right to assume that she has a more better control than the others?  

[Aqua Anjel]

Kittycharm

surprised

Well, I have a explaination for the question why Bella didn't act like a normal newborn.

She hated blood when she was a human.

Of course, turning into a vampire, she'd have to drink blood. But because she faints at the sight of it when she was human, isn't it right to assume that she has a more better control than the others?

It's not like Bella drank less blood as a vamp though. She had the same thrist, but she controlled it better with logic, not the hate for blood. So I don't think that's a fair explaination. And when she was preg with Renesmee, she was throwing back blood like it was nothing- as a human i might add...yet she used to faint at the sight of blood. Yeah, she wanted to do what was good for "the little nudger", but that type of psychologial phobia doesn't just go away- especially when it was so bad. I just think it was a cop out. The only explaination for her non newborn ways was that she was psychologly (i can't spell) stronger. But that whole, "She hated blood as a human" doesn't apply because she liked blood as a vamp.

Edit:// I just thought- pregnancy cravings can make you eat (drink) almost anything. But I still think she should've had some stuggle (even a little) when she was first turned.  

[.Bucket.of.Joy.]

I read on one interview with Stephenie that the reason Bella was no regular newborn is because she has so much time to mentally prepare for what was coming. All the others were changed without knowing what was going on, Bella on the other hand had about two years (correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it was about two. . .) to prepare herself for what was coming. She knew what would happen to her and she knew what she would be like. She was ready.

 

[Rin Kairiu]

The blood wasn't a phobia... she was just nausiated by the smell of it. It just made her sick. If it was a phobia then she would have run like the whips of hell were on her tail. whee

Anyways, I do somewhat agree that BD was a bit like a fanfiction, but I still liked it.  

[Aqua Anjel]

Rin Kairiu

The blood wasn't a phobia... she was just nausiated by the smell of it. It just made her sick. If it was a phobia then she would have run like the whips of hell were on her tail. whee

Anyways, I do somewhat agree that BD was a bit like a fanfiction, but I still liked it.

okay your right about the phobia bit, but my point still goes- she didn't like blood. And as a vampire, the previous human "I dont like blood" doesn't apply.  

[Rin Kairiu]

Oh, I know that... I was just making a clarification.

Also, I think why she actually liked the blood, while pregnant, was because of how the baby was affecting her body. It changed how she normally reacted to it, and pregnancy does that to you... gives you wierd cravings and stuff... like the eggs, lol.  

[Cassification]

My main problem with breaking dawn was how much I feel Leah should have found some happiness. I was all happy when she and Jacob started to get on and understand each other a little more, and then she was sort of left again, at least that's what it felt like to me. sad  

[Aqua Anjel]

Cassification

My main problem with breaking dawn was how much I feel Leah should have found some happiness. I was all happy when she and Jacob started to get on and understand each other a little more, and then she was sort of left again, at least that's what it felt like to me. sad

some Leah happiness would've been nice...^_^  

[KiraLight]

Wow..that was a really good uh..well lack for a better word, rant. Kudos to whoever wrote that. I whole heartedly agree with everything she/he said.  

[Spring and Summer]

What the hell is the point, exactly?
It's not like it will make ANY difference. They can't exactly UNpublish it.
So the whole idea is just idiotic.  

[Spring and Summer]

Aqua Anjel

Kittycharm

surprised

Well, I have a explaination for the question why Bella didn't act like a normal newborn.

She hated blood when she was a human.

Of course, turning into a vampire, she'd have to drink blood. But because she faints at the sight of it when she was human, isn't it right to assume that she has a more better control than the others?

It's not like Bella drank less blood as a vamp though. She had the same thrist, but she controlled it better with logic, not the hate for blood. So I don't think that's a fair explaination. And when she was preg with Renesmee, she was throwing back blood like it was nothing- as a human i might add...yet she used to faint at the sight of blood. Yeah, she wanted to do what was good for "the little nudger", but that type of psychologial phobia doesn't just go away- especially when it was so bad. I just think it was a cop out. The only explaination for her non newborn ways was that she was psychologly (i can't spell) stronger. But that whole, "She hated blood as a human" doesn't apply because she liked blood as a vamp.

Edit:// I just thought- pregnancy cravings can make you eat (drink) almost anything. But I still think she should've had some stuggle (even a little) when she was first turned.

Even as a human, Bella had sort of a protective force around her mind, obvious proof that her mind never has and never will work like anyone elses. Did you miss the part in the book where everyone is in awe at the fact that she is so controlled? So it's not like it was taken lightly in the book, and it's proof that it isn't natural and that no one knows why she can do that.