New Moon Depressing?

[hkkpfwg96]

I felt that it was very depressing. I'm glad that Edward came back.  

[Myakachii]

o_o; New Moon is my top favorite. Then Eclipse, Breaking Dawn, and Twilight.  

[lightpearl]

yes i cried when edward left.  

[twilight-lover-Team-Jacob]

I personaly liked New Moon the best out of all of the books.
Jacob is my favorite.  

[HeatherDraven]

At first I wasn't happy with the book because Edward and Alice left, those being my favorite characters, but I finsished it within one night and felt that it added to the story nicely. It still isn't my favorite but it was necessary to bring in the wolves and to have an opponent for edward. We have to love those love triangles. smile  

[Renaleen]

It was soooooo DEPRESSING!!! I tried to relate to how Bella felt so I could understand her, but it just got me depressed.
I hated Edward for leaving Bella! But then in the end, I understood why he left her. It was crazy, but such a great book! It seemed like Bella was just using Jacob though.. since Edward wasn't around much..... The more she talked about Jacob the more I liked him rather than Edward >.<  

[Juliette06]

It was just so sad. @_@ I felt like I could've skipped pages and pages of the story because it was all 'Bella: T_________________________T' with nothing else happening.

I do like Jake, though. So that was good. And I think there should've been a bit more explanation as to why Edward was leaving in the first place. I remember being all 'wtf' when I first read it. xD  

[BannedAccount8623822]

i love new moon it's my fav book of the series. my fav part is when edward leaves bella cause i can relate tat part to real life so much right now  

[sakura1120]

I personally loved New Moon. It's the base of Bella and Jacob's relationship, and it has so much emotion in it. It really makes me wonder what would've happened if she hadn't jumped off the cliff, and Edward didn't show up for another few months. When u look back, u realize she probably would've kissed Jacob in her truck or at her house, if Alice wasn't there.