the cup

[mostly_harmless]

I just had a thought. In one of the memories dumbledore showed harry, it said riddle stole the cup from a lady called hepzibah SMITH. and who else do we know with that surname? could this indicate that the key to the cup could be zacharias smith?
sorry if this point has already been dicussed  

[Rowena Marion]

not necessarily. Remember Mark Evans?  

[mostly_harmless]

I know what you mean but it is a bit of a coincedence that she had the hufflepuff cup and zacharias happens to be in that house.  

[covo]

Hmm...Maybe, I suppose it could be possible...  

[im2cool4skool]

thats a really good point. it could be true. or its just that a lot of people have the last name smith.  

[Kanami Hanaki]

I don't think it's been discussed before. Good point. But how is Harry going to get the cup by using Zacharius Smith?  

[mostly_harmless]

No idea whatsoever smile
Ideas Anyone?  

[Elvin_mist74]

Nope. Just reading and listening.  

[kitsunemajin90]

I think that's a really good point. But still, Riddle stole the cup, so how would Smith know where it was?  

[shlup]

mostly_harmless

I know what you mean but it is a bit of a coincedence that she had the hufflepuff cup and zacharias happens to be in that house.

well he could be a grandson, but i think j.k would of put hints(well more in the yearler books) about it if it was true(im not saying its not true im just saying i dont no lol)