Can something help me with a grammar question?

[Ksenia Sergeevina]

My teacher gave me this extra credit:
I was given the sentence, 'Women without her name is nothing.' I need to change the punctuation so the meaning of the sentence changes. So far I have two solutions. I need one more.

Women: without her, man is nothing.
Women, without her man, is nothing.

I will love you forever, , if you help me.  

[Fish Chum]

That sentence doesn't really make any sense to me.  

[Ksenia Sergeevina]

The sentence without punctuation or the other two?  

[s0prano42_x3]

I've heard this before from my choir accompanist. (haha) He did it these ways:

Woman, without her, man is nothing.
Woman, without her man, is nothing.

Those are the only two ways, I think. That first way of yours could be considered a third way, though.  

[Ksenia Sergeevina]

s0prano42_x3

I've heard this before from my choir accompanist. (haha) He did it these ways:

Woman, without her, man is nothing.
Woman, without her man, is nothing.

Those are the only two ways, I think. That first way of yours could be considered a third way, though.

I already posted both of those.  

[Bladeglory]

Should we really be doing your extra credit for you though?  

[Kohy]

I heard of this before. It was supposed to be a joke on how punctuation could change a sentence all together while supporting one gender.

Women in the class supposedly wrote: Woman, without her, man is nothing.

And the men in the class wrote, as you can guess: Woman, without her man, is nothing.

As far as I know, these are the only two solutions. I never heard of a third answer. But good luck trying to find it!  

[Ksenia Sergeevina]

I've asked all my friends, they only see two ways. Maybe my english teacher made a mistake.  

[ChibiStarlet]

I agree. I've only even seen those two and can't think of what else you could do to change the meaning. I think this was an example in Eats, Shoots and Leaves, too. Awesome book. cool  

[omiyashi0]

Ksenia Sergeevina

My teacher gave me this extra credit:
I was given the sentence, 'Women without her name is nothing.' I need to change the punctuation so the meaning of the sentence changes. So far I have two solutions. I need one more.

Women: without her, man is nothing.
Women, without her man, is nothing.

I will love you forever, , if you help me.

You need to change the punctuation? You changed that, and a word in the sentence. "Women without her name is nothing." Then it turned into: "Women without her man is nothing."

Which sentence is it?