Emmett or Edward??? Eh???

[Mrs_NickJonas288]

I think Edward would win, because Edward is more clever and does not just rely on his strength. razz  

[there was a silence]

well.. if you think about it.. Emmett is stronger, but he is also cocky, so he might just start punching or whatever. Edward would probably think about techniques and skills. Like when they were chasing Victoria in Eclipse, and she was dancing on the line, and Emmett just attempted to jump for her.. he probably wasn't even thinking. And Edward can read Emmetts thaughts, and know what he was going to do before he does it...

there for.. I say...

Edward... the smart one... =]

(I'm not calling Emmett dumb or anything)  

[Bam Its Joanna]

Joanna says...

I think Edward would win. Emmet may be stronger but Edward can read minds. Edward would know everything that Emmet would do and block his attacks. Emmet might get sick of Edward blocking his attacks and give up like Alice did when they played chess.

She wants your help. Joanna's Quest!!

 

[Nyx of the Moon]

I think Emmet may have the advantage with his strength but Edward has the Speed and might could dodge Emmet's attacks. I don't know who would win but it would be one hellava fight....  

[Tricky Little Vampire]

Fifii

The Kraken

Hm, tough one, tough one. Emmett is clearly stronger than Edward, but then Edward would most likely run away instead of fight. So, I dunno.

right he'd run away and thus forfeit, making Emmett the winner

Yeah, that'd make sense.  

[NiennaTaralom]

I think Edward would win, because he is very fast and he knows what Emmet thinks <:  

[EverybodysFooled]

If it was about Bella, Edward would win.
If it wasn't, I hate to say it, I think Emmett would win.  

[Teehee its Bee]

Definitely Edward! He is so much faster and thinks about what he would do before he does it.  

[alicecullen021]

Edward, Emmet may be strong, but Edward is faster, and Emmet is going for the ovious kill.  

[hospitalflowers]

Edward's a wimp, he'd dash like a turkey on Thanksgiving.

 

[the house of gaunt]

Edward probably.
He'd know how Emmett was planning on attacking him and could counter that attack.
But if Emmett's smart enough not to think of the attack, he'd win.

 

[Evelyn Electric]

Yeah, I'd have to say Edward would win. Brains over Brawns.  

[Kunoichi21]

Well, this is a tough choice. While Emmett is bigger and stronger, he's also somewhat slower. Edward has the advantage here because of his mind reading ability. Think of it in terms of relating them to animals. Emmett is like a grizzly bear, whilst Edward is like a mountain lion. Between those two, the obvious choice would be the bear, but the mountain lion is faster and more agile, thus able to dodge more attacks and be able to scratch the hell out of the bear. If it dragged out long enough, I think Edward would be the winner.  

[Jazmine_Twilight_Gurl]

I think, if it was just strength Emmett would win, of course

But if it was just a regular fight, i think Edward would win.

I mean, sure, Emmett has his strength nd all, but Edward would be able to read his mind and find holes that he could easily defeat him with, and mind you, he's the fastest.  

[Cecilia Rose]

Edward. Emmett may be stronger but Edward has the mind advantage. I also don't think either of them would be stupid enough to even start a fight.