is the movie going to be as good as the book???

[amanda_danielle]

what do you think? I mean they are cutting out most of the quidditch scenes!  

[Lady_Imrahil]

LOL. Well, they have to cut out a lot, or each movie would be like LOTR... especially because the fifth is the longest thus far.

I wasn't going to see it, because with the HP movies, I like them the first time I see it and afterwards, never again. They don't hold up like LOTR. However, the trailer I saw in Spiderman III made me excited to see it...

I didn't notice Luna in the trailer, and thus far that's my biggest concern--that they'll cut her out. I don't think it too likely right now though...

I think the movie will be all right.  

[hellomandy]

Lady_Imrahil

LOL. Well, they have to cut out a lot, or each movie would be like LOTR... especially because the fifth is the longest thus far.

I wasn't going to see it, because with the HP movies, I like them the first time I see it and afterwards, never again. They don't hold up like LOTR. However, the trailer I saw in Spiderman III made me excited to see it...

I didn't notice Luna in the trailer, and thus far that's my biggest concern--that they'll cut her out. I don't think it too likely right now though...

I think the movie will be all right.

I've seen Luna in quite a few trailers - with her radish earrings quite visible. I wouldn't worry.  

[lady-bug-britt]

i noticed that too
alot of the scenes are cut but then the movie wouldbe like 8 hrs (that would be sweet!)
but the movies get better and better as the years go
the graphics are rly neat!  

[Occlumens]

Yeah the movie won't be as good because like everyone said, a lot of scenes will be cut out. But it'll still be worth seeing.  

[x X Cissy x Black X x]

Well, obviously not, nothing can be "as good" as Harry Potter and the Order of the Pheonix~ heart But it'll be okay...  

[homeless_kiwi]

i cant wait for the movie to come, it will be in like 3 days here..........and im definitely gonna see it.....no matter how "unlike the book" it will be, its hard to make a movie, and i appreciate the ppl who try...  

[The Lady Gryphon]

Maybe it's just me, but I have yet to find a movie (based off a book) that was better then the book.

Not to say that, in most cases, I didn't find the movies very entertaining. whee  

[Grey Gardens]

How can it be even close to bad when we'll be able to see probably about half of the characters kiss smile

Or I'm just a pervert redface