New Moon Depressing?

[Twilight7448]

After finishing New Moon, I really felt the connection between Bella and Edward. I WANTED Edward. But I also felt it was depressing and very sad. The description of Bella's sadness went on for pages and pages. Because of that it was not my fave of the series.  

[KiwiDragon]

Yeah, I felt the same way. It was also weird to be reading so much of the book without Edward in it, although I understand why she did it. Still, it is not one of my faves either.  

[Lunanymph59]

new moon was the best book because it brought a lot of emotion.....
when i read it i hated jacob black and loved edward, but i really though connected wiith the book, like something totally tragic happened to me too when edward left.

but right now, i hate edward and heart heart heart heart jacob.

cheese_whine  

[.Bucket.of.Joy.]

It was extremely depressing. But that was what made it so beautiful.

It showed a much stronger connection between Edward and Bella that Twilight led us to believe there was. Plus, it made the plot much more viscus! It intoduced the wolves and the Volturi. That right thre is overflowing with conflict.

It was a great book.

 

[Lania_Forever]

It was depressing at first, but I thought it was a lot better when Jacob came into picture. I'm a big Jacob fan now. Actually New Moon is my fav now, but I haven't finish Breaking Dawn, so I might change my mind.  

[Beloved_angels_servant]

I found it very depressing cause alot of times while reading this book i was able to compare myself to how bella felt so i could understand her pain. It really sucks.
But I really loved it towards the ending cause you could once again see the strong feelings between bella and edward  

[Aqua Anjel]

it's very depressing, but i think that with out new moon, we would've never seen how deep bella and edward's relationship goes.  

[Shinku Anrui]

I thought it was depressing, yes, but I also thought it connected Bella and Edward a lot, so I still liked it. I was kind of mad that it was all Jacob and no Edward, but then I finished the series, so that was nothing compared to my feelings nao.  

[iJasper Hale]

lol New Moon really made me hate Edward for a while XD I got over it on eclipse, but I could never bare how he left her... so New Moon also made me mark for jacob x3  

[xXTwilight4LifeXx]

I'm re-reading the series right now, and I just got past the part where Edward left....

I felt lifeless til lunch at school.

New Moon was my least fave in the series.

Breaking Dawn was my fave.

biggrin  

[hkkpfwg96]

I think that it was totally depressing and for part of the book, I was not such a big Edward fan.  

[-3-Brokencyde-3-]

oml. I felt more anger then sadness because he juss left her like that nd turns out he didn't really leave i thought he should have never left. p.o. o.e but it was depressing  

[-3-Brokencyde-3-]

Twilight7448

After finishing New Moon, I really felt the connection between Bella and Edward. I WANTED Edward. But I also felt it was depressing and very sad. The description of Bella's sadness went on for pages and pages. Because of that it was not my fave of the series.

but did u feel any anger 4 wat Edward did?  

[-3-Brokencyde-3-]

hkkpfwg96

I think that it was totally depressing and for part of the book, I was not such a big Edward fan.

u may think that, but it almost killed him having 2 leave her as well but he's still hot biggrin except in the movie where it seems Jacob was the only 1 who looked cute he probably would have looked better if he got a shorter hair cut but in the book Edward is a total hottie xD xd xp xP  

[PyroDogs94]

Its my favorite book. <3 Jacob