Hollyleaf: Dead or alive?

[Night Witch the Third]

What do you guys think? I feel like this is somehow going to come into play at some point in the story.
But whether it will be for better or for worse has yet to be seen.
It would be awesome though if she somehow came back near the end of one of the books as a ghost to fight with her brothers to try to redeem herself.
Voice your opinions about Hollyleaf! What do you think?  

[Audrey 2 Returns]

I'm pretty sure she's dead. In the time line it says she's killed when the tunnel collapses. Lots of people try to come up with ways in which she's alive, but I guess we won't know until Erin tells us.  

[BarnOwl6-5]

I agree. Although, I do wonder where she would go if she died. She and Ashfur. Would they both go to StarClan, or the Dark Forest, or what? I don't think one bad deed would be enough to condemn them to the Dark Forest, don't you think? But murdering a cat (a fellow clanmate, no less!) is a pretty serious crime.  

[Night Witch the Third]

I wonder if there's a place where cats go if they are in between. You know what I mean? Like they don't belong in the Dark Forest, but they don't belong in StarClan either.
Anyways, it's great that Erin Hunter left Hollyleaf's disapearance vague enough to do whatever she pleases. That way if she doesn't know what to do with it yet, she's got possibilities. But I think she always had Hollyleaf's path marked out from the very beginning.  

[Bang the Devil]

I liked her more towards the end, when she went all crazy and stuff. My favorite part was when the tunnels collapsed on her. She was too whiney for me.  

[TheGuardianAngelsWing]

I liked it better BEFORE she went crazy...  

[xXRainbow_Veins]

Hollyleaf was still way too protective over the warrior code before she went crazy... but I think she found a way with Fallen Leaves, and then there might be a special book when Hollyleaf meets Fallen Leaves...
But personally, I hope Hollyleaf wont return. She might still be alive, but if she returns, I think jealously of Dovepaw might drive her even more crazy (if that's possible)  

[Bang the Devil]

That would be awesome if there was a fight between her and Dovepaw, or even her own brothers for "replacing" her! I would love to see who would win. Probably the three, you know, if they got past the fact that she's their sister. Otherwise, I think she would win. But it's probably not likely.  

[xXRainbow_Veins]

But who knows if she is accepted back into Thunderclan... you know, after she killed Ashfur... but that WILL be awesome ^)^  

[Audrey 2 Returns]

Who knows... stare  

[Bang the Devil]

Erin Hunter knows. And remember, Jayfeather and Lionblaze agreed not to tell ThunderClan that she killed Ashfur. They didn't want that to be the only thing she's remembered for.  

[Brooke Stream]

It's really sad what happened to Hollyleaf. She used to be so sensible and willing to do everything for her clan. Then she went crazy. Poor thing.  

[Red Devil Fire]

I hope she's dead. twisted  

[xXRainbow_Veins]

Red Devil Fire

I hope she's dead. twisted

haha, as much as i think she's alive, i also want her dead... i never liked her when she became an apprentice... too... firestar-like