The drought of living death.

[unopend]

There is an editorial on mugglenet that was VERY convincing, interesting, thought out and plausible.
here is the link for teh editorial.

do you believe it?
Does it belong in Jo's rubbish bin?
your thoughts?  

[Twinkleh]

Hmm,it makes sense and the things well thought out.
Even so,how will it finally be revealed?
But I guess if she can hide a Drought of Living Dead in a scene,she can do anything. xd  

[kitsunemajin90]

I admit that it makes sense, but I wouldn't stake anything on it. It is possible that it is the Draught of the Living Dead, or it could mean nothing. The idea is interesting though.  

[dancr321]

harry potter rox right?  

[covo]

Wow that's a really good theory, I like it.  

[o_sugarsweetie_o]

i aggre with you..

dancr321

harry potter rox right?

 

[Lurielle is unkind]

It's definitely plausible that the water was the Draught of Living Death, but JoRo has been known to put minor details into the story that are never explained fully in the books. The Cat-kneazle crossbreeding is one of those things. (see the Rumors section of her official sight, under the rumor of crookshanks being an animagus)  

[savannatiger09]

Bravo!!! Simply ingenious......Maybe Dumbledore isn't dead after all. Even though he got hit by Snape's killing curse. He might've done a countercurse while he was falling down from the Astronomy Tower. rolleyes  

[mscarrieb]

wow... that was a really amazing insight into J.K.'s writing lol. Ahh how much would it rock if Dumbledore was just sleeping?