Tia Dalma or Elizabeth Swann?

[Trolly Troll]

which is better??? hmmmm....

Elizabeth cons: Has Will ( very angry at the fact that she has Will! not fair! not fair!), killed Jack, a littled spoiled if you ask me, annoying ( notice that she is the danzle in distress...uh...not really in the 2nd one but in the first one for sure!)

Elizabeth pros: she is pretty brave, she is pretty, she is nice, protects Will ( yay! but....somehow im not happy that about cause i wanna protect Will hehehe yeah im crazy but in a good kinda way) and like she is independent so yeah

Tia Dalma cons: a little crazy, needs to take a bath, a little freaky, she flirted with Will in the 2nd one ( lol) ,

Tia Dalma pros: shes nice, she can tell the fortune ( always a pro lol), she gave Jack his jar of dirt so that if Davy Jones came, he would be protected, she's very cool in a freaky kinda way lol and she is brave in my opinion


hmm...both of pretty cool...which one do you choose?  

[Davy Jones Hidden Heart]

I choose Tia Dalma because she didn't chain Jack up to the mast. And she's just awsome. 3nodding  

[this is captain rose]

TIA CUZ LIZZI IS EVIL I WILL KILL HER I ALREADY DID IN MY MIND 1000 TIMES SHE MUST DIE!!!!!! (i think she will in the 3rd though...) DIE DIE DIE DIE DIE!!!! MUAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA DIE!!!!!!!! twisted twisted twisted twisted twisted twisted twisted DIE!!!!  

[xTsunam1x]

Well, first of all I think you're wrong about Elizabeth killing Jack. I don't believe they would actually make him die. C'mon you're talking about Captain Jack Sparrow. He was bound to come up with some escape. Coming back to the actual topic.. I think Tia Dalma is a little more intriging than Elizabeth. And back then I don't think many people took baths anyway.  

[[Hockey.Ch!ck]]

...[+] Sea turtles mate. A pair or them strapped to my feet ...

I would have to say Elizabeth...
Sadly I have the same personality as her.
sweatdrop

... Not so easy is it?. [+]...

 

[Davy Jones Hidden Heart]

xxP1rateGrlxx

Well, first of all I think you're wrong about Elizabeth killing Jack. I don't believe they would actually make him die. C'mon you're talking about Captain Jack Sparrow. He was bound to come up with some escape. Coming back to the actual topic.. I think Tia Dalma is a little more intriging than Elizabeth. And back then I don't think many people took baths anyway.

Actually I think he did die in a sense. Cause think about it. If he didn't why would he be in purgatory pretty much and if he didn't there would be no reason for the great Barbossa to come back. Remember, I said I think he died in a sense, not an actual death. 3nodding But thats just my take on it.  

[Morgensterrn]

to be honest. i'm not a big fan of either of them. I think i like Elizabeth a little better than Tia. Both are pretty anyoing though lol  

[Death_In_Black]

Personally, I like Tia more. She's dark, cool, uses witchery, etc.  

[fallout.boyy]

Elizabeth ftw.  

[Enki Ankarian]

Tia is my favorite, because drinking ink takes intestinal fortitude.
That and her creole makes me want to dance.  

[x-Nadia-x]

Captain Rose

TIA CUZ LIZZI IS EVIL I WILL KILL HER I ALREADY DID IN MY MIND 1000 TIMES SHE MUST DIE!!!!!! (i think she will in the 3rd though...) DIE DIE DIE DIE DIE!!!! MUAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA DIE!!!!!!!! twisted twisted twisted twisted twisted twisted twisted DIE!!!!

Yes, because she practically sentenced jack to death. crying I cried in the movie theater  

[Helsinki_Vampire616]

Tia Dalma. The only problem I have with Elizabeth is she chained Jack to the mast...  

[Ryuuki-sama]

POTC wouldn't 'be' without the main three(Lizzy, Sparrow and young Mr. Turner), however Elizabeth's chaining of Jack to the mast made me cry and Tia gave Jack the dirt to protect him..
Dirt to protect, chain to kill...*weighs options*

TIA DALMA!! domokun  

[bubblegum_freak]

Tia Dalma. She's a helluva lot cooler than prissy Elizabeth Swan.  

[commandercool101]

bubblegum_freak

Tia Dalma. She's a helluva lot cooler than prissy Elizabeth Swan.

3nodding