Billy and Charlie

[6vampire6mistress6]

Yes, I've been thinking again. One day this'll be hazardous to my health haha Charlie's lived in Forks for a long time, and he seems to know Carlisle better then most people. Is it possible that he isn't as human as he seems?

Now for something I've been pondering for quite a bit now. We all know Billy's in a wheelchair and stuff, and I believe an explation for that was given in Twilight. Or was it New Moon...? Anyway, I don't think he was telling the whole truth about what happened. I don't think Billy is a human.

What say you?  

[Fifii]

the explanation was in twilight, and i think they're human, the town gossips so of course charlie knows stuff, and billy is just billy  

[Glitterbean]

I agree, I think they're both human.  

[Faye_26]

I think Charlie is just a innocent human, that has his suspisions. Billy..I'm thinking that he might be a werewolf..or maybe his grandfather was, Billy knows more then he lets on. xp

 

[lost_smile]

Well Billy is obviously different because the whole werewolf jean runs through his family he may not be directly effected by it but he is different.  

[niecerpiecer]

But Jake didnt say anything bout his dad being a werewolf he just said something bout his great grandfather being the leader or somthn 3nodding  

[featherbee]

i agree. billy does have the werewolf gene in him but i don't think he's anything special(eclipse may prove me wrong)and charlie probably wouldn't let bella date edward if he knew he was a vampire. i do think that edward's mom knew about carlisle though.  

[Strings of Destiny]

I thought billy was a werewolf confused  

[edwardlover26]

Fifii

the explanation was in twilight, and i think they're human, the town gossips so of course charlie knows stuff, and billy is just billy

i agree with this...